Ok, I haven’t made this in a loooong while, and all my searches come up with gourmet garbage I don’t want. I have 2 cans of 5alive concentrate and a 2-litre of Lemon-Lime soda. My usual, IIRC was put in the concentrate, 1/2 the water called for, and the whole 2-litre bottle, if it will fit. The simplest base? Right. I’m not doing all the fancy sliced fruit, or adding Kool-Aide or Jello mix. Just the bare bones punch for a family gathering.
So, not enough water, or too much? Been cooking all day, and now the wife wants to know what is for dinner. (Early Thanksgiving due to family being in town.)
I would throw some grenadine in, but it is going to be in a plastic pitcher. Wouldn’t even be very noticeable.