AL MVP (Top 3)
Cabrera
Davis
Machado
AL Cy Young (Top 4)
Sale
Masterson
Shields
Scherzer
NL MVP (Top 6)
CarGo (Big lead)
Gomez
Goldschmidt
Cuddyer (nipping at heels)
Votto
Segura
NL Cy (flawed) (Top 3)
Kershaw
Wainwright
Zimmerman
Pardon my ignorance, but why do you say “NY Cy (flawed)”?
It left off Matt Harvey.
I messed up including all relevant stats.
Left Darvish off the AL list too. Is he even trying? Not sure.
Darvish is also a contender. (I’m not trying, merely providing food for thought) 
I’m not sure about the MVP and Cy Young awards, but they ought to just give Puig the NL Rookie of the Year award now and get it over with.