MLB September 2026

If you’re going to seed on the regular season records, why not just dispense with the entire post-season and award the WS trophy to the best regular season record?

IMO that would be a far better measure of actual sustained merit than any conceivable playoff format. And frankly, IMO MLB’s playoff format is the best of the various major US sports.

Of course we know they’ll never dispense with a post season - that’s where all the money comes from.

As a separate matter, why not dispense with divisions and maybe even leagues? The whole season could be a giant round-robin of all the teams. That too would eliminate the issues with weird record match-ups. And then you could have a post-season elimination, World Cup style, of the e.g. 16 teams that are the regular season MLB-wide leaders.

I don’t have an issue with divisions and leagues. Right now we have two great division races involving four so-so teams. While home field in baseball isn’t quite as important as the NFL or NBA, it still isn’t right that a .500 team gets to host a far superior squad.

Only races left:

  • HOU and TEX for the AL West
  • PHI and AZ for the last NL Wildcard slot, and the seeding for the NL WC spots
  • CWS and CLE for the AL Central, although both are in the playoffs

As I type this:

  • HOU is tied in the 3rd against ATH
  • TEX is getting killed by MIN
  • PHI lost to TB
  • AZ is beating SD
  • CWS won
  • CLE is beating KC

White Sox and Guardians both won. Cleveland remains a game ahead of the Sox with two to play. The Sox hold the tiebreaker.

Phillies lost and DBacks won. Phillies have lost 3 in a row while Arizona has won six in a row, and now trail the Phillies by just one game. The Diamondbacks hold the tiebreaker.

Houston and Texas both lost and both have records of 79-81. This means that for the first time in MLB history, a division winner will not have a winning record. The Astros hold the tiebreaker.

I’m just so damn proud of my home division. Kinda gets you right here. :kitchen_knife: :broken_heart:

MLB has seen the popularity of the NFL which has had teams with losing records in the playoffs since 2010, and decided it’s time to get with the times.

In the AL, the only race still active is for the Central. Either it will be HOU or TEX, but all the byes and WC seeds are locked in.

In the NL, there’s still a race for the last WC spot between AZ and PHI. The seedings for the 3 WC teams are still up in the air. SD is either WC1 or WC2. CHC can be in any WC spot. PHI can be WC2 or WC3. AZ can only be WC3.

Remember: you don’t have to be good to win a division. You just need to be the least bad team in that division. :zany_face:

Which IMO goes back to my point that it is the division and league system which creates these performance inversions where low performing teams enter the post season over higher performing teams. And where low performing teams get home field advantages, or first round byes which is what the wildcard system amounts to.

Another fun year! My teams in order are Cubs, Phillies, Dodgers, Red Sox since I was a wee lad. Kinda glad Cubs are playing Padres in better weather.

Phillies are sucking ass. Completely. Today was a huge nightmare. Now down to a Phillies loss tomorrow with a D’Backs win puts the D’Backs in 6th and ousts the Phils. WTF? If Phils had won one or two of their recent division games, they wouldn’t have to worry.

Do the Padres care about winning tomorrow? I will mentally bet Phils lose, D’Backs win. We’ll see around 4:00 EST.

12 year MLB veteran Kirby Yates, 39, has announced his retirement after making his first career start. In his career, which has spanned 8 teams (Rays, Yankees, Angels, Padres, Braves, Rangers, Dodgers, Pirates), he’s pitched in a relief role in 517 games.

Coincidentally, in his first career start, he pitched against another pitcher retiring after the season, Justin Verlander.

Per ESPN:

Note: Yates signed with Toronto a few years ago, but never appeared in a game due to a groin injury, so I didn’t include the Blue Jays among the teams he pitched for.

And this morning the only remaining NL postseason question is Phillies / DBacks for the last NL wildcard slot. Who play Tampa and San Diego respectively this afternoon. Both formidable opponents. Hard to say who will win either of their games.

PHL will retain the wildcard slot unless they lose and DBacks win. If so, DBacks advance & Phillies are done for the year. Any other outcome ends the DBack’s season & Phillies retain the wildcard slot into the playoffs.


The AL still has their wacky situation out west where the as-yet undecided division leaders (Astros & Rangers) are both too crappy to qualify for their league’s wild card. Sheesh. Astros will take it unless they lose to Oakland, and Rangers win over Minnesota. Minnesota is playing decently and Oakland sucks, so it’s looking like the Astros are in better shape to take the division.


In all 4 significant games on the last day of the regular season. I didn’t try to check, but IMO it’s not too often that happens.

The Dads just clinched their spot last night, so I have to think they’ll be playing their reserves mostly.

It’s always an imponderable when a team with (almost) no stake in the outcome plays a team with a large stake in the outcome.

And as you say, especially so if the no-stake team does have a big stake in their own subsequent games. Which is the key difference between the NL & AL situation today.

In the AL West case there’s no tomorrow for either of the Rangers or Astros opponents. They Do. Not. Care., except as to team rivalries or their personal trade value. Twins and Athletics getting an early start on their R&R by being extra careful not to get hurt, or even just phoning it in gotta be tempting.

Brewers clinched #1 seed a while ago (possibly before win 100). Other than going for record wins, any reason not to rest folks for the postseason (or have they? I’m obviously not a big follower)

Brian
At least one Wisconsin team is doing well

The Brewers have a bye in the first round of the playoffs, so they get most of a week off anyway — their next game after today is on Saturday. What I’ve seen is that they are only letting the starting pitchers go a few innings over the last week.

Since when are all 3 wild card games at the higher-ranked team’s ballpark?

I think since they added this 3 game round.

Correct. Since 2022.

So the field is set.

American League

On to the Divisional Round

  • Tampa Bay Rays (Best Record)
  • Cleveland Guardians

Wild Card Round

  • Chicago White Sox at Houston Astros (Division Winner) (and even this Cubs fans says, “Go Sox!”)
  • Boston Red Sox at New York Yankees

National League

On to the Divisional Round

  • Milwaukee Brewers (Best Record)*
  • Los Angeles Dodgers

Wild Card Round

  • Philadelphia Phillies at Atlanta Braves (Divisional Winner)
  • Chicago Cubs at San Diego Padres - Go Cubs Go!!!

/* “Actually, it’s pronounced Mee-Lee-Wah-Kay. Which is Algonquin for ‘The Good Land’” - Alice Cooper.

I’ll be rooting Yanks of course, but also WhiteSox and Cubs.

Just don’t care Phillies and Braves.