Whether it’s baseball, American football, baseball, basketball, hockey, soccer, and I’m sure with cricket, rugby and other team sports, there are teams or clubs that are full of talent and potential, who fall woefully short of winning championships or titles. These are well-documented and linger in their fans’ minds and hearts forever.
But there are also teams that have won a championship or two who should have won more. They were so superior for so long that their limited success was not enough.
For US sports, a team that probably first comes to mind is the Chicago Bears of the mid-80’s. Yes, they won one Super Bowl. But that Buddy Ryan defense was amazing, and they had enough talent on offense that everyone thinks they should have won multiple Super Bowls. They even had the audacity to record and release the Super Bowl Shuffle , proclaiming that they would win the Super Bowl, well before the regular season even ended. They won that year , but that was the only one. I think their Achilles heel was their QB Jim McMahon.
Another is the MLB team the Atlanta Braves of the mid- to late- 90’s. They had the starting pitching staff of a generation. 3-4 dominant pitchers back when they went deep into games. But they only won the 1 chip, thwarted by Padres and Yankees teams.
Please share more, and I will as well.
But let’s please limit this to team sports, and not individual sports like tennis or golf. That could be a whole different thread.
The Green Bay Packers, with Brett Favre, then Aaron Rodgers, and now Jordan Love at quarterback.
They have been a consistently a good-to-great team for the past 30+ seasons, after wandering in the wilderness for nearly 30 years after Vince Lombardi retired.
For all of that, they have only two Super Bowl wins to show for it: one with Favre, and one with Rodgers. They lost one other Super Bowl under Favre, and their last Super Bowl appearance was now 16 years ago; they’ve lost the NFC Championship Game four times since then.
The Cleveland Indians of the mid 1990s. They had Albert Belle, Manny Ramirez, Kenny Lofton, Sandy and Roberto Alomar, Eddie Murray, Omar Vizquel, and several very good pitchers. They went to the World Series in 1995 and 1997. They were in the playoffs for 1995-1999, 2001, but never won it all.
Hmm I guess this doesn’t quite qualify for the OP. Sorry.
This is going way back, but the Milwaukee Bucks won the NBA championship in 1971, with a stellar record of 66-16. The team featured Kareem Abdul-Jabbar and the Big O, Oscar Robertson. The next year they went 63-19 but lost to the Lakers in the finals. They were good for the next couple of years but never made it back to the finals, and then Kareem was traded to the Lakers in 1975.
Earl Weaver managed the Orioles across 15 seasons (in his first stint) from July 1968 to September 1982. His teams went 1354-919, a .595 winning percentage, won four AL pennants but only one World Series title.
Weaver was an excellent manager, and those teams, especially with their pitching staffs, never had a losing season. He had the misfortune of being in the same division as the “Bronx Zoo” Yankees, and then retiring the year before Joe Altobelli won the Series with the team that he had assembled.