Somewhat inspired by this thread Vote here: Most irritating mainstream magazine, I thought it might be a kick to see what people think is the most thought provoking/best written magazine published today.
I personally think that both Atlantic Monthly and The Economist are both well written and thought provoking publications.
Loathe as I am to give credit to a magazine with that title, The New Yorker does do it right.
I’ve only started readingNational Geographic in the last few years, and the articles are usually as good as the photography. (Which magazine has the largest ratio of subscribers to actual readers, Nat’l Geo or Playboy?)
My favorite, though it’s really a paper rather than a magazine, is High Country News, especially their syndicated columnists, who are known as Writers on the Range. As the OP asks, the columns are consistently well written and thought provoking. It’s environmentalism by the people who are live in the environment they write about, as opposed to the “fly-in/figure it all out/fly-out” stuff you get from, say, Outside or Mother Jones. Try it: http://www.hcn.org/wotr/
I’ve been a Harper’s fan for years. I’m in the middle of a three-year subscription. I even sent them a résumé—no, I actually brought my résumé into their lobby in December 1996. They didn’t call. I did the same for Mad, offering my services as a proofreader. They didn’t call, either, but a couple of months later, the cover of “Maad” magazine announced, “Proofreader wanted.” Coïncidence? Probably… but I like to think I inspired something.
Biotop—Beer Frame is one of the greatest magazines out there. I’d certainly call it thought-provoking. Murder Can Be Fun isn’t what I’d call thought-provoking, but certainly worth a glace or two.