Leads who (in your opinion) aren’t as good as supporting cast members (actor repeats allowed)
Kevin Costner, Prince of Thieves
JK Simmons, Whiplash
Miles Teller is OK in his role as the young drummer who wants to learn under Simmons and even looks good in scenes drumming but he’s no match for Simmons.
William H. Macy & Tea Leoni, Jurassic Park III
Sam Neill actually has top billing, but they are 2 & 3, and Neill isn’t any better, while Trevor Morgan, a rare watchable child actor, carries a lot of the movie, and the other secondary characters are much more vibrant and developed than the top three.
Lucille Ball, Mame
She can’t sing, and her acting is all wrong for the tenor of the story. The child playing young Patrick outshines her by miles, and Bea Arthur reprises her stage role beautifully. What is worse is that the Broadway actress who is dumped for the movie and replaced by the more bankable Ball was Angela Lansbury.
Lucille Ball, Mame
She can’t sing, and her acting is all wrong for the tenor of the story. The child playing young Patrick outshines her by miles, and Bea Arthur reprises her stage role beautifully. What is worse is that the Broadway actress who is dumped for the movie and replaced by the more bankable Ball was Angela Lansbury.
And great list of responses to the Leads who were out-acted category above; I didn’t expect actors like Robert De Niro or Daniel Day-Lewis there, but I can see why.