Well, I am a big soundtrack collector, and what I suggest you start to do is start looking for is the composers that you like, because you’ll see that you’ll be drawn to some more than others. (I gather from the soundtracks you’ve mentioned—which are, I believe, mostly orchestral—that you are at least partially looking for scores). Scores are not always the same as soundtracks. Soundtracks can either include original scores written specifically for the film, or can be “compilations” of songs gleaned from other sources. But I’ll concentrate on scores here, and their composers.
Everyone knows who **John Williams** is, and he’s a good place to start. He’s not all “Star Wars” either. “Schindler’s List” is supposed to be pretty good (I have it somewhere) and “Phantom Menace” is wonderful. He’s got some non-epic-sweeping scores (“The River” comes to mind) that you might enjoy as well. An oddball (but delightful) score that sounds very un-Williams is “The Missouri Breaks”—weird Country music. Weird, but good. Williams is, I think, unjustly pigeonholed as a “big sweeping epic” composer, but he’s more than that. You have to search a little, but he’s done some really different and beautiful scores that don’t sound like “Star Wars”.
My personal favorite is **Jerry Goldsmith**. He’s been around forever and has got so many styles it’s hard to describe just one. He’s done a lot of the “Star Trek” scores (“Nemesis” is pretty good, though the first “Star Trek” movie score did get nominated for an Oscar, and for good reason.) “L.A. Confidential” has this weird moody bluesy style (also Oscar-nominated) that you may or may not like. “Under Fire” (another Oscar nominated one) is a must-have of Goldsmith’s, in my opinion. It’s got a South American sound and features guitarist Pat Metheny. Goldsmith is also famous for “The Omen” (which he did actually get an Oscar for) and “Planet of the Apes”. These are two unusual scores that are not as melodic and beautiful as, say, “Under Fire”, but are brilliant nonetheless. He has written about as many scores (or more) than John Williams, and in my opinion, he has a few more “styles” up his sleeve. But they’re both very good.
**James Horner** is another perennial favorite, and is also Oscar-nominated. “Titanic” is a beautiful score, as is “Braveheart” (he did that one, right?). A favorite of mine is “The Devil’s Own”. A beautiful score. I personally think that Horner’s scores from the '80s are a little weak, but that could be just me. His stuff from the '90s and beyond is pretty good to outstanding. You can’t go wrong with Horner.
**Danny Elfman** has such a wonderful sound, I love him too. He does seem to have an instantly recognizable “Elfman” sound (but I guess the other guys do too) but I never tire of him. He’s done umpteen scores, but a favorite of mine is “Edward Scissorhands”. Beautiful, beautiful score.
Hans Zimmer got an Oscar (I think) for “Lion King”, and he’s fantastic too. I recommend “Gladiator”, “Crimson Tide”, and “Green Card” since I own these and love them to death. Looking at his filmography, I can’t think of anything he’s done that I haven’t liked. Man, he’s fantastic.
Then there’s Thomas Newman. He never ceases to amaze me, and I know I need to get more of his scores. “American Beauty” and “Scent of a Woman” are what immediately spring to mind when I think of him, but looking at his filmography, he’s done so much more—so much. He has this kinetic style that is gentle yet fascinating. I can’t describe him too well, other than his sound is beautiful and he’s going to be around for a long time, I predict.
I don’t know a whole lot about Carter Burwell, but his score for “Conspiracy Theory” is fantastic—fun, jazzy, very energetic. One of my favorites. And I see by his filmography that he did incidental music for “O Brother Where Art Thou”. Hmmm… I need to get that score too.
Yeah, I obviously could go on and on. One thing I will tell you—just because you don’t like the movie, it doesn’t mean the score won’t be good. Take the “Rambo” series, for instance. Not my cup of tea at all, but damn! Jerry Goldsmith did a fantastic job on the scores, (I grudgingly admit) so I own all the CD soundtracks, which feature Stallone’s glistening body gracing the CD covers. (Blech.) What can I do? The scores are great. And sometimes, a good score can pick up a lukewarm movie.
Yeah, yeah, I know I listed a lot of composers. And I almost left out one of the best, **Ennio Morricone!** (He did the Spaghetti westerns, and SO much more. He’s brilliant.) So many composers, too little time…