25th wedding anniversary (ours, to be specific), and we need to load up the iPods.
Dan Fogelberg’s “Longer”, and Huey Lewis and the News’ “Stuck With You” are required, of course.
What else must we have?
We will of course have other music. It wouldn’t be “us” without a full rendition of Weird Al Yankovic’s repertoire, for example.
“Anniversary” by Voltaire. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PT1-B-sS_Lc
Me and Mrs. Jones - Billy Paul
Let’s Stay Together - Al Green
“Memories are Made of This” by Dean Martin
“Follow” by Genesis
“In Your Eyes” by Peter Gabriel
"Right by Your Side " by Eurythymics
“You’re the Inspiration” by Chicago
“Endless Love” by Lionel Ritchie
I started to compile a list from this site, but this seems easier…have at it!
“Stuck In the Middle With You” - Stealers Wheels
“Faithfully” - Journey (might be too sappy tho)
“When I’m 64”
Then I’d look for songs that played when you were dating.
Might not be fully appropriate to your situation but You’re Still The One, by Shania Twain.
Excellent link - thanks! AND - when I played snippets of some of them on iTunes, one of the things that came up was a link to songs of the year 1983 with even more suggestions.
OK, maybe I’ll skip a few of them - not quite sure I want to explain Marvin Gaye’s “Sexual Healing” to the 9-and-unders who will be there 
Wonderful other suggestions, guys - thanks! (erm, lieu, “Me And Mrs. Jones”? Isn’t that about someone committing adultery? )
You know, I fully expected to be able to go to Wiki or some site and show that the lyrics were just a play on emotions and words, that “Mrs. Jones” was in fact his wife and they were playing, a married couple acting as if their continued attraction for each other was almost adulterous. I thought it was just one of those songs where people usually misinterpreted the lyrics where they in fact meant the reverse. I took it to be a love song.
But all I can find now suggests you’re right! Oh man, Mama Zappa, I’m so sorry. Heh, let me amend that to “Whatever you do, don’t play Me and Mrs. Jones!”
Let’s Stay Together though, I’m still hoping you find room for it. If that one means something else I’m gonna need a therapist.
That’s what I would do…find the songs popular 25 years ago. Do you remember what song you danced to at your wedding reception for your First Dance?
Thought I’d post an update with what we wound up putting on the list:
After the Fire, Roger Daltry
All I’m Thinkin’ About, Bruce Springsteen
Anniversary, Voltaire
Blue, Red and Grey, The Who
Enjoy The Silence, Depeche Mode
Faithfully, Journey
Follow You Follow Me, Genesis
Gimme All Your Lovin’, ZZ Top
Here Comes The Sun, The Beatles
Hurts So Good, John Mellencamp
I Melt With You, Modern English
In Your Eyes, Peter Gabriel
It’s Inevitable, Charlie
Let’s Stay Together, Al Green
Longer, Dan Fogelberg
Love Reign O’er Me, The Who
Memories Are Made Of This, Dean Martin
Octopus’s Garden, The Beatles
Our House, Crosby Stills and Nash
Right By Your Side, Eurythmics
She’s My Girl, Tom Lehrer
She’s the One, Bruce Springsteen
Somebody, Depeche Mode
Something, The Beatles
Stuck With You, Huey Lewis And The News
Such Great Heights, The Postal Service
Tender Is The Night, Jackson Browne
Thing Called Love, Bonnie Raitt
When I’m 64, Beatles (or Accidentals)
White Wedding, Billy Idol
Without Your Love (MacVcar), Roger Daltry
Wonderful Tonight, Eric Clapton
You’re The Inspiration, Chicago
Your Song, Elton John
You Make Me, Weird Al Yankovic
Some of them are unusual choices, but then we’ve got an odd sense of humor 
As y’all can see, we incorporated many suggestions from here. Also did some nosing about in published Imixes on Itunes, and the Weird Al song was accidentally added to the list (not sure how though) and we decided we liked it 
Note - the above was posted by me, not Typo Knig :smack:
Though he was standing watching me post it, so I imagine his consent can be taken as given!