My "Open Letter" to Fucking IDIOTIC YouTube Video Posters

Ok, not all of them. Just the ones who post absolute crap.

Why the fuck do they post this stuff??

My “open letter” to said posters (I’m sure the overlap between said posters and dopers is approx. 0.00%, but I’ve got to start somewhere…):

First, remember that you are posting into a highly competitive environment. There is some insanely awesome stuff on YouTube. YouTube viewers live in a world of instant gratification. We viewers live in a world where with one click we can view that which is astonishing and otherwise rare to be found. We are spoiled rotten. Keep that in mind.

On that note:

DO NOT edit an overly long, complex, amateurish introduction onto the front of the clip. Nobody cares that you know how to create swirling and fading titles and wipe cuts. Nobody cares about meaningless details that have no relevance to the clip. We get “it”: You’re clever. But guess what: Nobody cares. Just show us the goods. We want the money shot. Just because you have the latest video editing software on your computer doesn’t mean you are Steven Soderbergh.

ASK YOURSELF: “Is this clip, by any measure conceived, going to be interesting to anyone in the fucking slightest?” And I don’t mean, to you. Nobody cares if you like it. I mean, is this going to be interesting to anyone else on Planet Earth (and Mars too, I just heard they got DSL). Think long and hard about that. I’ll start you out: Nobody gives a fuck if your cat falls off of a coffee table. Nobody cares if your Grandpa snores (unless it is literally shattering windows, then put it on YouTube). Nobody cares if if you throw a water balloon at someone and it doesn’t break. Nobody cares if you videotape someone jumping out of a cardboard box. Nobody cares.

INVESTIGATE whether or not your new-found, amazing clip has already been posted 800 million times. Ask yourself, “Gee, I pulled this amazing clip off of CNN. I wonder if anyone else on the planet has had the brilliant foresight to post this on YouTube already”. I assure you, the answer is “Yes”.

Oh yea, and what’s with accompanying the video clip with that high-fructose, hyper-manic techno dance music??? I’m going to let you in on a little secret: It’s fucking garbage. Absolutely. It drives people mental. It licks donkey balls. Right now, somewhere where they have donkeys, there is a donkey frozen in his tracks by the sudden and overwhelming realization that he is part of something greater than himself. He valiantly struggles with furrowed brow to grow a third ball specifically intended for lick-age in this matter. Good little donkey. So, unless your clip is actually set in a nightclub, leave the “DJ FuknTalntlessS” audio at home. Save the donkeys. Please. Pretty Please. Anymore techo and I’ll be scooping my ears and eyes out with a spoon.

Still on music, PLEASE don’t accompany your video with a song that was burnt out 1000 years ago. I mean, ok, so you did a “Troop Tribute” video. Great. Don’t accompany it with “Welcome To The Jungle” by “Guns ‘N’ Roses”. I mean, what, do you actually think that we are going to realize: “Wow!! What a visionary and cultural quantum-leap you just made by associating that song with that video!!! Wow! Do you see what he did there? The video shows troops fighting. And it IS like a jungle, after all, man. And he matched it up with “Welcome To The Jungle”!!!”… Well, I hate to be the one to tell you this, but you’re not exactly single-handedly rescuing Western Civilization by playing the lonely, single-candled monk creaking his old bones down into the archives to check that the rain water isn’t dripping on the manuscripts. I was burnt out on “Welcome To The Jungle” when you were still smearing your poop on the wall while contemplating no further than whether it was the horizontal or the vertical strokes that had greater artistic merit.

And another thing (and this is going to blow your fucking mind): When you title your clip: “Alligator rides unicycle while doing long division”, I want to see AN ALLIGATOR RIDING A UNICYCLE DOING LONG DIVISION. I don’t wanna see no crocodile, I don’t wanna see no regular bicycle, and I don’t wanna see no fucking calculators. Abacus?.. maybe. An Alligator using an abacus would be alright, I guess. Ya dig? So that means if your title is “Can of Beans Explodes in Camp Fire”, ask yourself, “Self, does this clip specifically and, in fact, exactly show a can of beans that is, in fact, exactly NOT exploding in the slightest?” If the answer to that question in any way resembles the word: “Yes”, then RE-TITLE THE CLIP or, better yet, DON’T post it! For example, this is a “Jet Pack” video. Thisis not. Review. Rinse. Repeat if needed.

Get it together, morons.

[END TRANSMISSION]

So the kid with the RC car should be controlling the “Tsar” instead?

Trenelle06, is that you?

I’m sorry?

Geez, there are now standards for one of the best venues for simple human expression–a free front-row seat at the Human Comedy in all its splendor–to come down the pike since the Internet itself?

Well.

I guess it was just a matter of time before the Grups got in there and started messing it up for everybody.

I would suggest that the mere ability to express oneself is not license to pollute.

Can I assume that by “Grups” you mean “grown-up in the minority”?

Regardless, I’m actually trying to clean it up for everybody.

That Jetpack video is badass!

The music thing absolutely kills me - idiots with shit taste and no sense of irony accompanying perfectly great clips (such as the fight scene in “Oldboy”) with shitty, stupid fucking music clips (like adding that horrible Linkin Park song to it).

I agree with the sentiment - the world is full of idiots. But for my money YouTube is exactly where they need to be expressing themselves. If not there, where? Here?

YouTube is a fantastic place. I thank *Zeus’ balls that **I’m alive at this time (and thanks for the cool links, Shamster) and that I get to see all the cool shit that is there. But it’s us intellectuals that are the uninvited guests, IMHO.
*Proof
**More proof

I’m not sure I understand why I shouldn’t use youtube to share inane videos with friends and family. It offends your sensibilities somehow?

And the first examples you gave of “great” youtube content are just grabs from TV broadcasts. Way to enrich the world. :rolleyes:

Also, I thought that one of the great things about the internet is that it contains information of all sorts, not just committee-approved stuff.

Where are they supposed to go? Man, I don’t know… can’t we just give them balls of yarn, or something?

Don’t get me wrong, I love YouTube. It’s totally amazing. I just wish we didn’t have to trim off so much fat to get to the meat…

Touche

Yeah…most of the people I know that have YouTube accounts just use it as a video host more than anything.

Yea, it does. “Please Don’t Litter”. If you are sharing inane videos on YouTube, then I’m not surprised you don’t understand why you shouldn’t do it… Actually, I’m just joking around with you. It’s cool that you’ve found a way to swap videos with family.

It’s just that I have this vision of what a “perfect” YouTube would be like: All meat and no fat. All 4 or 5 stars, no 1 or 2 stars. I just find the current incarnation frustrating and banal. But hey, that’s just me…

Who cares where the video is sourced. Awesome is awesome is awesome. And while TV is certainly not inaccessible, YouTube does improve the availability of that TV content which is not common and is important.

Yea, you’re right. But there is a downside to that, as well.

I found this AP article earlier tonight, and this bit caught my eye:

They’re just as much about the amateurs as MySpace is, and I think we all know what that place allows its users to do to their web pages. shudder

“Kimi Räikkönen’s lap in the first qualifying session of Monaco Grand Prix 2005. Commentary by James Allen & Martin Brundle.*****” and " Japanese Learning English*****" are important in what universe?

CMC fnord!

You know, as i read your OP, i was thinking the exact same thing about the SDMB.

Well, an on-board camera shot of an F1 car racing around Monaco is visually stimulating and generates appreciation of the driver skill required to accomplish such a thing. I think that’s YouTube worthy.

And the Japanese crime-fighting aerobics video is comedy of the highest order, surely.

But I understand what you’re saying. What is YouTube worthy? It’s all relative. And for me, there’s too much suckage on YouTube. But hey, that’s just me.

Awww, c’mon. It’s the BBQ Pit. This is where we go to blow off steam, is it not? :slight_smile:

Don’t be the Princess Leia to my Han Solo… you found my OP irresistible.

Exactly. I’ve got a bloody cat video there, and I don’t even have a cat. Was there an easier way to show it to several friends? I suggest to Shamozzle that if you happen upon it, don’t waste your time complaining, just move right on.

But there’s just so much of it. It bogs me down…

And I want to complain. It drives me nuts.

So…

I kind of liked the Teletubbies one.

I mean, it doesn’t even come close to any of the three the OP listed as being examples of good YouTube clips. But for what it was, I thought it was decent.

I mean, I hate the music too, but then, I hate the Teletubbies. The clip did a nice job, I thought, of recontextualizing both. Here I’d like to say something articulating the effect of the recontextualization, but I got nothin’.

Well anyway. :slight_smile:

-FrL-