Wrong Then, Right Now and On the Beach at Night Alone by Hong Sang Soo.
Life imitates art or art imitates life.
Right Now, Wrong Then is about a movie director visiting a town to speak a festival of his films. He meets a young artist (played by Kim Min Hee) and despite being married attempts to have an affair with her. The movie is split into two parts, each depicting what could have happened.
Like most of Hong’s films, the movie is brilliant. But it’s especially noteworthy because following the release of the film in 2015, rumors began that he was having an affair with Kim Min Hee, whom he met for the first time during the filming.
Throughout 2016, he and Min Hee denied the affair, but in 2017 during the premiere of his next movie starring Min Hee in Seoul, they admitted they were in love, but have never acknowledged they were actually having a physical relationship. The movie is On the Beach Alone at Night where Min Hee plays an actress having traveled to Hamburg to await her married director love to arrive.
Min Hee, best know to international audiences for Park Chan Wook’s The Handmaiden, ended her agency contract in 2016 reportedly due to the rumors of her affair, and in 2017 lost all her endorsement contracts following her admission of her affair.
Since 2017, Min Hee has starred or appeared in almost all of Hong’s movies, which Hong claims aren’t based on reality, but some of the parallels with real life is often blurred.
Two more most see Min Hee “movies” are Lee Je Yong’s Actresses and Behind the Camera. Both films are shot in mockucumentary style, but it’s unclear what is and isn’t scripted. In “Actresses”, six actresses ranging from veterans to newcomers come together to do a magazine photoshoot. Tensions and truths?* rise as the day goes on.
*There’s a scene where Go Hyun Jung and Choi Ji Woo get into a verbal fight and Hyun Jung acknowledged what she said wasn’t scripted.
In Behind the Camera, Min Hee again plays herself. Again, the movie is shot in mockumentary style and it’s even more again it’s unclear what and what isn’t as the cast of the movie waits for the director who has decided to do his direction from a remote location.