I am allowed to auto-notify anyone by email for 1. New listings, 2. Price changes, 3. Misc. changes, or 4. Back on market. That’s all. Supposedly the reason for that is exactly what you said, to enhance their desire to work with me.
This MLS uses a Navica engine, and I checked with their tech support about this. They said not allowing solds for auto notification was by design, so potential clients would contact agents.
So these two philosophies are at odds, I think. Anything I can feed to a potential client is better coming from me than from some other source. Knowing about sold properties is valuable information for all parties and it is not kept secret. In fact, I am obligated by ethics to inform buyers of solds if requested.
Note that there are no restrictions in this MLS system as to searching for solds (or hundreds of other criteria) and emailing the results to anyone. It is only the auto search that has this limitation.
One person I would like to put on the auto-sold email list runs a Welcome Wagon business. She wants to know when new owners will be moving in the area so she can take them a greeting package. And she might be pleasantly disposed towards me should she need real estate services.
Another party may sell in the future. He wants to keep on top of prices for good reason.
For that matter, I would like to be emailed about solds in certain areas as well. Although I check the hotlist at least once daily, which shows everything that has happened in the last 24 hrs, I also get instant emails for certain areas for new listings and price changes, which can be very useful. I just can’t get it for solds.
I will be mentioning this to our board, who can make Navica change their software and policies, but it might cost and many agents are Luddites with computers and might not want any change. I am reminded of a conversation with one of the most successful agents in my area, about 16 years ago, when I suggested to him that he put listing detail on his website (all he had then was minimal; didn’t include prices, for example). His response was one of horror. “We can’t do that! Then buyers wouldn’t have to come to us!”
My, how things can change.