Meanhoo McCaffery had 221 yards from scrimmage.
Could anyone explain what happened at the end of the Raiders Seahawks game? What are the rules on batting a ball?
The Raiders kicked off with 2:03 left, being behind they tried to kick it out the end zone so the Seahawks would have a snap before the 2 minute warning. Horton jumped up and batted the ball to prevent it going out of play and then told Shaheed to pick it up and run it out the end zone so the Seahawks 1st down would be after the 2 minute warning. He was tackled at the 19 yard line.
The TV rules expert was saying this was totally legal and Mike McDonald was congratulating Horton and then the Referee announced it was an illegal bat but the penalty was declined.
What made it an illegal bat (if it was) and what would the penalty have been if it wasn’t declined?
Here’s the video of the play.
From the NFL rule book:
ARTICLE 1. ILLEGAL BAT. It is an illegal bat if:
(a) Any player bats or punches a loose ball in the field of play toward his opponent’s goal line;
(b) Any player bats or punches a loose ball (that has touched the ground) in any direction, if it is in either end zone;
My bold.
So a player cannot bat the ball if it’s in the end zone. Penalty is 10 yards.
I don’t know why the Raiders declined the penalty, as I assume it would have been assessed from the dead-ball spot. Unless it would mean a re-kick.
12.5.1:
It is an illegal bat if:
- any player bats or punches a loose ball in the field of play toward his opponent’s goal line;
- any player bats or punches a loose ball (that has touched the ground) in any direction, if it is in either end zone;
- an offensive player bats a backward pass in flight toward his opponent’s goal line
- a forward pass that is controlled by a player prior to completing the catch is thrown forward (the ball remains alive if caught by a teammate or intercepted).
What Horton did isn’t a violation of the batting rules.
The ball hadn’t touched the ground, which is part of the rule you’re citing.
Correct, I didn’t see that when I watched the video.
But…he did bat it toward his opponent’s goal line. But was it a loose ball? Probably not, so it was legal. Good call.
Loose was defined in that rule as having hit the ground. If the ball was bouncing out of the end zone after hitting the ground then absolutely that should have been a penalty, I’d agree with you.
It was a weird move, I don’t think I’ve ever seen it before, so I totally understand the confusion including from Klint Kubiak who thought it was a penalty. It’s one of those “we gotta look that up” sort of situations.
![]()
Surely if it wasn’t a loose ball (and therefore legal) it was a bad call. The refs took a long time to make there decision, which the TV reckoned was with discussions with New York, I looked up the definition of a loose ball
“A ball that is not in the possession of a player and that is considered live and able to be recovered by either team.”
https://www.glossaria.net/en/american-football/loose-ball
I’d have thought that would mean the ball after a kick off is not a loose ball as the kicking team can not recover it hence my confusion.
Regarding the penalty being declined I was guessing it was something like The Raiders could retake the kick-off from somewhere further up field but wouldn’t get the time back. In any case it seems that the Seahawks benefitted by committing a penalty, which is something that will probably result in a rule change for next season.
The Refs said it was an illegal bat I think Klint must have been unhappy with what would have happened if he accepted it. From the Play by play record of the came this is the description of the play.
“M.Gay kicks 68 yards from LV 35 to SEA -3, impetus ends at SEA -9. R.Shaheed to SEA 19 for 22 yards (D.Luter).Penalty on SEA-T.Horton, Illegal Bat, declined.”
That 46-40 is a scorigami!
Purdy’s 389 passing yards is a career high. CMC’s 161 receiving yards and 74 yard receiving TD are both career highs.
And if they’d scored their two-point conversion at the end of the previous game, it would be 7 games by less than 5 points.
Steelers look shot in this game.
ETA: The score of this game looks like a college game score.
Except a kickoff is a loose ball once the ball has traveled far enough. Or maybe it’s not anymore because the NFL keeps changing the kickoff rules every season. I have no idea.
Well, the kicking team can recover the ball after an onside kick. It used to be that any kickoff is a live ball, but that may have changed.
If it lands in the landing zone then proceeds into the end zone it becomes a live ball. That was a new rule as of 2024.
If a kick hits in the landing zone and then goes into the end zone, it will be considered a live ball (can be recovered by kicking team) that must either be returned or downed by the return team.
Otherwise it isn’t a live/loose ball until touched by the receiving team as usual.
Sounds as if the refs* got this wrong but given the penalty was declined it didn’t make any difference in the game.
* Literally refs, the game had two refs on the field.
Aidan Hutchinson is out for the season with a torn ACL.
He’s going to have lots of time to stop and think about what he’s done.
Former ref Gene Steratore was acting as the rules analyst commentator, and he insisted there was no flag for what it’s worth.
Rules analyst Gene Steratore said on the CBS broadcast that “I don’t think it’s a foul. It’s a kick that never hits the ground. I believe you can bat a kick in the air provided that it has never hit the ground yet […] it’s a first for me though, fellas.”
Shocking. A bad refereeing call. ![]()
At least it was zero impact.
Bengals 38 Steelers 18 was also a Scirigami, thanks to the Steelers’ odd choice to go for 2 after scoring a touchdown when the score was 31 - 3, and then not go for 2 after scoring another touchdown when the score was 38 - 11.