NFL 2026-2027: Week 10

The Chargers looked like they sold out on the run, daring Baltimore to win through the air.

Worth noting this is Brissett’s first game with the team, and he’s the 4th QB they’ve started so far. No team starting 4 different QBs in a single season is having a good time.

Tough first season for Jesse Minter

That’s only if it hasn’t gone 10 yards yet. Traditionally, and I assume still today, a kickoff down the field is fully live the moment it travels 10 yards. If the defender just lets it bounce on the ground, the kicking team is free to jump on it. I’m unclear if they’d be allowed to advance it, but it’s absolutely live without the receiving team touching it.

Possibly you were mixing it up with a punt?

True, it’s live, that’s how onside kicks work. But it’s not “loose” until it hits the ground, for the context of that rule (because it’s explicitly mentioned in that rule).

Is that still true? With the change in kickoffs recently, the kicking team has to declare when they will attempt an on-side kick. If they don’t declare it and kick away, is the ball still fair game after 10 yards?

There’s another question I’ve always had about on-side kicks. The kicker always kicks the ball to roll along the ground. I’ve always wondered why. Couldn’t some kicker devise a way to kick the very bottom of the ball so that it pops up in the air? A short, high kick would give the kicking team time to get to where the ball will land, and then it’s a jump ball for whichever team can grab it first. I’ve always figured there was a rule that the ball had to go 10 yards and also touch the ground before the kicking team could recover.

It’s been tried. Just about every possible way to kick a ball has been tried. Turns out it’s tough to do consistently. Teams and kickers also don’t practice it a lot. If you are regularly attempting onside kicks that you get consistent practice, something has gone terribly wrong with your team.

Also, if you pop it up high enough, one of them can signal a fair catch, and interfering with that is a penalty. That’s also why you see onside kick attempts often kicked off the ground to pop up - you can’t fair catch it if it hit the ground first.

As for the rest, the ball only has to travel the 10 yards on kickoffs. It doesn’t have to hit the ground at all. The NFL rule, as written, is actually that the ball has to reach the receiving team’s “restraining line”, which is 10 yards for regular kickoffs but 15 yards for safety kicks.

But if it is kicked short without declaration, even if it was not deliberate, it’s almost certain the officials are going to toss the flags and sort it out after. You might get away with that once, maybe, but probably not. Kickers are too good these days to muff a kick off a tee like that.

It can’t be, because a kickoff that lands short of the landing zone is a penalty, and the landing zone is much farther than 10 yards from the kickoff. It would also make the rule about the ball becoming live when it hits the landing zone and going into the end zone redundant.

The 10 yard rule only applies to onside kicks. I forgot about those other rules I quoted in this very thread. :laughing:

Speaking of which, on Sunday, the Falcons executed the first successful onside kick this season against the Chiefs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9b_thzpYDo

Week 11 thread

It’s easier to successfully pull off an onside kick when the receiving team’s closest player doesn’t make any attempt on the ball.

The Packers lost ground to the entire division!! :grinning_face:
If you want to know how strong the NFC North is, the Bears dropped from first place to third place simply because they didn’t play. LOL

This week’s “extinction event”: The Baltimore Ravens lost at home to the winless Chargers to go 4-6. Without Lamar Jackson, they’ll be fortunate to win 3 more games this season.

I’ve seen the popup onside kick attempted here and there, and it has succeeded on a few rare occasions. Usually it is hit such that it would land 5-10 yards behind the +10 yard line, with the idea being the kicking team cover guys can run in there before the receivers and grab it out of the air.

This is true, and also you will notice that in a traditional onside kick, the ball is intentionally kicked in a weird way to make it tumble a lot. The point of that tumble is to make it unpredictable and hard to recover. A ball that’s popped straight in the air is easy to predict; it’s going to travel in a predictable arc. A tumbling crazy ball is going to bounce and jitter and all kinds of crazy stuff.

It’s true that the tumbling ball is a gamble, but if you’re attempting an onside kick you’re already at the point where you’re desperate and you’re trying to succeed on a very low percentage play with a ton of risk. There really isn’t any legal spot you can kick a ball that makes it more likely that a member of the kicking team is going to be able to get it than the receiving team, so you might as well just make it hard for everyone to recover and hope you get lucky.

Reminds me of one Pittsburgh kicker Chris Boswell did. Worked great in college back in 2013 but screwed it up when he tried it in Pittsburgh

Here’s the clip where he absolutely nailed it in college. And the complete flub in 2016 in the NFL

A predictable arc is not a problem, as long as it’s high enough for players from the kicking team to get to where the ball is going to land. A Hail Mary pass is a predictable arc, too, but players from both teams are waiting for it to come down. A short, high, on-side kick could be like that, except the ball is still live if it hits the ground.

I wonder if @Great_Antibob had the answer; teams don’t on-side kick that way because the receiving team can just signal for a fair catch. Can you do a fair catch on a kickoff?

Not under the current NFL kickoff rules.

Rule 3-9:

A fair catch is an unhindered catch of a scrimmage kick that has crossed the line of scrimmage and has not touched the ground or of a free kick that has not touched the ground, by a player of the receiving team who has given a valid fair catch signal. A fair catch may be followed by a fair catch kick

And definition of a free kick:

A free kick is a kickoff, safety kick, or onside kick that puts the ball in play to start a free kick down.

So yes.

A scrimmage kick and a free kick are different things. No fair catches on a free kick, they are only allowed on a scrimmage kick.

Fair catches on kickoffs were allowed behind the 25 yard line between 2023 and 2026 but that has been removed by the new dynamic kickoff rules.

Read the rule again.

A fair catch is an unhindered catch of a scrimmage kick that has crossed the line of scrimmage and has not touched the ground or of a free kick that has not touched the ground

It explicitly contradicts you. Maybe they haven’t updated their rules but they say they’re in effect in 2026. And I can’t find anything that supports what you claim even though my gut says you might be right.

All the articles I’ve read on the Dynamic Kickoff rules are explicit that there are no fair catches allowed. As you pointed out, that’s not spelled out in the rule book. Not sure how to resolve the two.

As a watcher of football, I can’t see why a person would call for a fair catch. Either the ball lands outside of the landing zone and it’s a foul, or in the landing zone and it has to be returned, or out of the back of the end zone for a touchback, or in the end zone and kneeled for touchback or returned. So maybe there’s no need to put it in the official rules because it just doesn’t actually apply anymore.

Like I said, my gut was telling me you’re right.

Funny enough, an onside kick (where the dynamic kick rules aren’t in play) might be the only kind of kickoff where you might actually do a fair catch, though you’d have to kick it high enough for it to make sense.