No fireflies in Buffalo - why?

There are fireflies (or, as some people would call them lightning bugs) all over the Cleveland area. Fireflies are also supposedly common in Rochester, New York.

The climate, vegetation and topography of the Buffalo area isn’t much different than that of Rochester or Cleveland, but sadly, there aren’t any fireflies blinking around the suburban – or exurban, or rural – night skies in the area. Why?

Not to highjack, but maybe to expand the OP…

What ecological niche do fireflies fill? My friends from overseas tell me that there are no lightening bugs there. They are facinated with sitting in my back yard and watching the show. What bugs fill the same niche over seas?

Toronto. They are just so dazzled by the lights they head north, eh.

There are fireflies but they are not nearly as dense as in other areas I’ve seen that had them.

Umm, make that last sentence “There are fireflies in Rochester …”

Fireflies are evidently becoming extinct. It would seem that some of their species already are.

Do you have a cite for the claim that there aren’t any fireflies there? Even in rural areas? I find it hard to believe, as they are all over New York state. I can personally vouch for a fairly large population in Syracuse and Utica, NY. Perhaps you are looking in the wrong places? They tend to fly close to the ground, in grassy areas, in my experience. You won’t see them everywhere. If your claim about Buffalo is really true, then I’d be seriously concerned about pesticide use in that area.

I live in New York City and see them on my lawn every evening. I second MaceMan suggestion of checking what insecticides are being sprayed in your area.

You’re not he only one who finds that firelflies in Buffalo are rare.

Fireflies

In Buffalo (well, the suburbs), I’ve never seen fireflies. I did, however, see them about an hour and change south, in the more rural southern tier (Sardinia-ish).

I was born and raised in Buffalo, attended college and graduate school there, and visit my parents in suburban Buffalo every few weeks.

If it’s the pesticides, Inwonder what’s so different about pesticides used in the Buffalo area compared to what’s used in Rochester, Syracuse, Cleveland or NYC? The densely populated suburb where I live sprays as if pesticides are free, and the fireflies are still abundant.

Darnit, I was just about to vouch for fireflies in the Fredonia area (well, closer to Laona, and that actually makes a difference geologically as that is where the hills start, whereas Fredonia is more like Buffalo being on the coastal plains…)

As long as we’re all chiming in…I’ve been in Orleans County (which is a very rural section of WNY) for twenty-two years and I’ve only seen one firefly in that time.