Obsession (2026): Is It Fair to Treat Bear as an Allegory for Male Entitlement?

Fake Nikki used the wish willow to make Bear fall in love with her, which made him instantly stop trying to vomit and go be with her, which killed him.

Plus the choice to give Nikki the last name “Freeman.”

Was Bear morally obligated to sacrifice his own life to save Nikki? He didn’t actually intend the wish to work when he made it, and he certainly didn’t intend for her body to be possessed by a spirit. I think he was obligated to try to reverse the wish, but not necessarily to sacrifice his own life.

Yes. Through his own actions an innocent person is going to be tortured for the rest of her life. It’s his duty to stop that immediately.

I haven’t seen Obsession, but I think it sounds like it fits into a familiar pattern appearing in a lot of horror/dark-comedy/psychodrama/thriller films:

A transgressive act by a male character is used not so much as an allegory about real-world male behavior, but rather as the springboard for a narrative exploring a self-terminating fantasy about transgressive male behavior, which ends up being punished by death (or nearly).

American Beauty: responsible ordinary family-man guy wants to shuck his stifling middle-class middle-age social obligations and fuck a beautiful teenager. Doesn’t end well.

Fatal Attraction: responsible ordinary family-man guy takes advantage of his family’s weekend absence to succumb to what he thinks is a no-strings one-night stand with attractive co-worker. Doesn’t end well.

Being John Malkovich: sad-sack unfulfilled married guy has the hots for attractive co-worker, manipulates supernatural events so she wants to be with “him”. Doesn’t end well.

(Arguably) The VVitch: stiff-necked Puritan paterfamilias disputes a doctrinal point with the community in his precariously established North American early colonial settlement, gets the whole family banished to isolated location. Further on, horny adolescent son is attracted to blandishments of mysterious beautiful young forest woman, gets seduced. Doesn’t end well.

And so on and so on. In short, lots and lots of these “doesn’t end well” movies start off with a guy kicking over the traces and pursuing something he wants (because isn’t a man supposed to be able to have what he wants??). And then Nemesis catches up to him, and usually everybody around him as well.

So in general, I don’t think of this standard narrative as an “allegory for male entitlement” in the sense of tut-tutting about “see, this is how men in real life are such selfish domineering brutes, isn’t it awful”. Rather, I think it’s narratively compelling partly because on some level our patriarchal society is fascinated by the question “is a man supposed to be powerful and effective and independent and take the things he wants, or is a man supposed to gain social acceptance and recognized manly status by successfully following societal rules? What happens if he abandons the latter path to strike out along the former? Might that… not end well?”

You’re right, I haven’t seen the movie in a while and I forgot some parts.

Also just wanted to add that there is nothing textual in the film that says “Nikki is possessed by a demon.” That’s just a fan interpretation. It’s really just “wish version Nikki” and “real Nikki.” It’s two separate identities, but that doesn’t mean it’s a demon.

To me, a big part of Bear’s entitlement is that Nikki is the one who has to change. He could have wished for self improvement, to be more confident, better looking, taller, richer, smarter, or whatever[1]. The toxic attitude that if girls aren’t into you, then there is something wrong with the girls.

Viewing Bear as well meaning but misguided, to me, means disregarding Nikki’s perspective. She is the one that loses agency and is put under the control of a man’s desires. The real horror is what she goes through off screen, or some trite statement like that.


  1. of course monkeypaw rules apply, so it never would have ended well ↩︎

I have to defend Bear somewhat, at least when we’re talking about the events of the movie prior to and including the wish. Bear is grieving the loss of his grandmother and his cat. He’s lost two major attachments in his life. Becoming romantically fixated on one person for comfort in that situation may not be the healthiest response, but it’s a deeply human one.

Bear makes his wish spontaneously, in a moment of emotional frustration, without expecting it to actually work. It’s easy for us to identify morally preferable wishes when we know the magic works and have had time to consider the implications, but Bear didn’t have that.

Wanting someone to love you is not the same thing as feeling entitled to their love. I wish Jeff Bezos would give me 10 million dollars. Is that selfish? Yes. I want money and I would prefer not to work for it. There. I said it. But I don’t actually expect him to give it to me, and I’m not terribly surprised or outraged that he’s not doing that.

It’s mostly the moment when he acts offended that Nikki doesn’t want to be his love slave that instantly shows you who Bear is. Yeah, his wish is in the big scheme of things a harmless thing we have all done. He also had basically zero non life ruining options after the wish was made. He is still an asshole.

But this “innocent” wish still comes from a place of entitlement. I agree, he didn’t know it would work and might have thought it over more if he did. But without a great amount of thought, his first impulse is still to wish for a change in the girl.

The fact that people see that as understandable given the circumstances is the problem. This is what makes it more than just a story about one jerk, and turns it into a commentary on male entitlement.

I fundamentally disagree. Simply wanting something like love is not the same thing as demanding it from others, and labeling that “entitlement” seems like an improper description. It seems to be labeling a natural human desire as toxic. At least, it’s labeled like that when it comes from a certain subset of men who aren’t romantically succesful. I don’t think women ever get labeled as “entitled” for expressing these feelings.

Yeah, I remember a very specific first-star-wishing formula that I used in middle school about the boy I had a crush on. It was worded differently (and, I flatter myself, much more thoughtfully) than Bear’s wish in Obsession, but it was no less presumptuous in that what I was wishing for was the nonconsensual imposition of a change in his feelings and desires, which was not my call to make. And I don’t think that anybody’s inclined to call that “an allegory for female entitlement” or whatever.

Of course, one important difference in those scenarios is that back when I was making such wishes, I was eleven or thereabouts. Long before I had reached the mid-20s life phase of Bear in the movie, I had given up wishing/hoping/praying that other people would just spontaneously start feeling about me the way I would like them to.

Maybe that is reflective of some kind of socialized gender difference in attitudes, though? Girls are expected to learn to accept and prioritize boys’ feelings as they are, while boys are still seeing girls’ feelings as potential wish objects?

Pre-wish Bear is using romantic fantasies as a coping mechanism. Not the healthiest thing, I’ll concede. Just like how people turn to drugs to regulate their emotions. But I wouldn’t label the fantasy itself as evil.

I wonder if Fatal Attraction has something to say about the same problem from the opposite gender POV? For reference, Dan is the male protagonist in that movie and Alex is the female.

I know that film was mentioned upthread as exploring the ever popular question: “If you cheat, will it all go wrong?” And in Hollywood, the answer is virtually always: “Yes, it does go wrong. Badly wrong”. I want to talk about something else.

Pretend Dan is single instead. He agrees to have a one night stand with Alex, a single co-worker who’s not a subordinate. Nothing wrong with that as such. Now the rest of the movie unfolds pretty much per the script, net of Dan not having a family for Alex to terrorize.

She’s clearly someone who is pursuing her agenda as to him with no thought to his agency or his interests. She wants a slave and won’t take “no” for an answer.

What does her character have to say about American civilization and the generic woman’s “entitlement” to affection, etc.? Arguably Alex has more agency in her ongoing behavior than Bear does with the demon’s (or whatever term) behavior inside Nikki’s mind. IOW, Bear inadvertently opened Pandora’s Box. Alex is Pandora’s box.

My bet is it doesn’t say much. She’s out there, way out there.

But at the same time there are millions of women with BPD in the USA. Some of them are really very much like her.

Bear is no more a male archetype than Alex is a female archetype. They’re both very poor examples of well-adjusted humans. But Earth contains a lot of poorly adjusted humans.

Interesting that you should mention BPD, because I’ve seen Wish Nikki’s behavior compared to Borderline Personality Disorder.

And I see that fantasy as involving change in a woman, not in himself. It is a very natural reaction, but it still comes from a place of entitlement. Women certainly aren’t immune to this either, but our society has a bit more of a problem with male entitlement than the reverse.

I agree with you here, and maybe this is a sticking point in our discussion. I don’t see Bear as evil, but he is certainly poorly adjusted and has a sense of entitlement. And there are a lot of men out there who are not evil, but certainly feel entitled to a woman’s affection. So while I do think the movie has something broader to say about male entitlement, I also think it’s taking it too far to say Bear is evil.

My best guess about what would have happened if Bear never encountered the One Wish Willow: He would have kept quietly pining away for Nikki without ever telling her. Possibly for years. I don’t think he’d go on an incel forum and rant about it. He’d probably just suffer quietly without bothering anyone. Maybe he goes into therapy to work on his low self esteem, and he gets into a relationship with Sarah. But that would be a pretty boring movie, wouldn’t it?

Wish they’d made Sarah less attractive, her being a hottie on par with Nikki just makes Bear a dumbass. If she was more on Bear’s level that would have made the movie better.

I think he was only told those were his only two options, after Bear was asked if he simply wanted to end the wish and instead Bear requested if he could “modify” it. That moment was Bear’s villain turn.

It is unclear what would have happened to the events of the movie had Bear initially requested to just end the wish from the get go.