Obsession (2026): Is It Fair to Treat Bear as an Allegory for Male Entitlement?

Eh, the heart wants what it wants. If someone has a crush on a particular person, you can’t just swap in any reasonably good-looking person of that same gender and assume they’d feel the same attraction.

Choosing to alter the wish may have been the cautious option, not the greedy one. Cancelling a supernatural wish is a drastic step with unknown consequences, and Bear has just learned how badly a casual wish can go wrong. Wanting to adjust it, not blow it up, could come from fear of making things worse. A person burned by one reckless act might not trust himself to make another without more information.

He does ask to end the wish, after being told they can’t modify it. I doubt the answer would have been any different if he asked for that from the get go. The wishes are evil, there is no good outcome to be had there, the real Nikki is in some hell. Ian wished for something harmless and he died in less than five minutes. The tech support guy tells him the wish doesn’t stop until he dies. Nikki is the one that asks him to kill her. So those are the only two options Bear had.

I am curious what the magic store clerk wished for, he seemed content! Could be if you wish for something simple it actually works well.

There is a trans pride flag behind him that wasn’t there when the clerk was a girl, maybe they are the same person.

I read an online interview with Curry Barker (I can’t remember where, but I’ll try to look) where he talks about this. He said that it’s not meant to be exactly the same as the monkey’s paw story, where the wishes inherently come with an awful price. He said that the bad consequences came because the wish itself, or at least the way Bear worded it, is what was evil. So if Ian hadn’t run over to Bear’s house, he probably would have been fine and been able to enjoy his billion dollars.

I’m sorry but that makes zero sense. Even the most unkind interpretation of Bear’s wish would not lead to what happened unless the wishes themselves were evil. Bear didn’t even get his wish, the movie made it very clear that wasn’t even Nikki that loved him. If that was his intention he failed miserably at conveying it in the movie.

While I haven’t seen the movie, based on reading this is where I’d fall. It’s a human trope.

This thread contains substantially more thought about the premise than Curry Barker put into it. He’s comedy YouTuber who knows how to market things, and he’s very talented at that. I don’t think he’s a deep thinker, or the kind of guy to make insightful social commentary.

A lot has been written about Barker and Kane Parsons, another YouTuber who made a feature film around the same time (Backrooms). Parsons took an internet meme and made a thoughtful movie, while Barker took an interesting premise and made an inconsistent horror film.

And now I need to step out, because I’m just being a hater.

Well, for what it’s worth, here’s the interview:

Obsession Filmmaker Curry Barker on the Inspiration Behind the Film’s Horrifying Twist

In a twist on the classic Monkey’s Paw scenario, Barker says the One Wish Willow doesn’t necessarily produce cursed outcomes. It all depends on the wish that’s made. “Everyone thinks the One Wish Willow is cursed, but it’s not. Like if you worded it very, very carefully and wished for something you knew couldn’t possibly be bad for anybody, you’re probably fine,” he says. “But if you’re forcing someone to feel a certain way about you, it doesn’t really matter how you word it.”

I have to agree with @steronz . I see it simply as a “be careful what you wish for” story. I suppose a viewer can treat anything they want as whatever they want, but I don’t believe any of what we’re talking about is the film maker’s intention.

Even if it wasn’t the film maker’s intention, every now and then a blind pig finds an acorn. It’s still a a legit question what we see in the film. And how we think it maps into the real world.

It’s unclear to me how much Bear is simply an emotionally obtuse confidence-free mostly unobservant goof. Versus an actively motivated force for evil. His was an outcome very similar to Eichmann in Jerusalem → Banality of evil - Wikipedia in that much evil was done with no such particular goal. Pull quote:

Banality, in this sense, does not mean that Eichmann’s actions were in any way ordinary, but that his actions were motivated by a sort of complacency which was wholly unexceptional.

Bear wished for someone else to be changed to fit what he wanted. That’s on the face of it an evil wish, or fine if you don’t want to say “evil” it’s at best selfish and egotistical and completely devoid of feeling for the other person, and the film plays that out. It wasn’t a neutral wish.

(I like the idea that the salesclerk was trans and wished to be in a male body, now that’s a wish that is only what that person wants and doesn’t take away agency from someone else.)

If wanting someone to love you is a flaw, it’s a deeply human flaw that quite a lot of us have. I don’t think it’s villainous in and of itself or else we’d have to label a broad swathe of humanity villanous. Probably a majority, if we’re being honest.

The wish happens 17 minutes into the movie. I’d be curious about something. We show an audience who has never seen the movie before the first 17 minutes and then pause it, asking them if whether they sympathize with Bear or find him to be an objectionable person at this point.

Wanting someone to love you and making a specific someone love you are two different things.

If you wanted someone to love you, you could wish for, I don’t know, an instruction manual in what to do and say to lead to that outcome, or if it didn’t have to be a specific someone, maybe wish to get a text with the name and location of a person who will fall in love with you easily.

But magic mind control is never a good thing.

How does Groundhog Day fit into this? For reference, that film’s male protagonist is Phil, female is Rita.

Due to magic that Phil had no hand in causing, he’s stuck in a one-day time loop only he notices. Eventually he decides he wants to woo Rita. So each day he refines his pitch until it finally works. Which breaks the spell. Cue happy ending.

The film of course is played for laughs. But looking at it from the many Ritas’ collective POV, it’s a much less pretty picture. Phil’s enjoying the chase and eventual success, but meantime, umpteen other iterations of Rita have been stalked, outraged, and simply gotten unwelcome attention delivered in ways she doesn’t prefer from men she’s not interested in.

But all Phil is doing is mere self-improvement and some amount of “know your audience.” Just done on a very concentrated time scale. IOW, what many here are saying that Bear should have wished for: self-improvement, not remodeling Nikki’s mind.

Is Phil Capital E Evil? Lowercase evil? Or a victim of the time loop trying to at least enjoy what’s left of his perhaps eternity trapped in Feb 2 in Punxsutawney? How much self-interest is permissible in romance before it becomes creepy?

Here’s a situation where I think the well-known Bechdel Test can be a useful concept. I.e., does a movie have at least two named female characters who talk to each other about something other than a man?

Certainly not every movie has to pass the Bechdel Test, and not every movie that doesn’t pass it is a bad or sexist movie. But as a rule of thumb, I think if you’re writing a movie about a woman eventually falling in love with a man whom she initially isn’t attracted to, and you’re not even thinking enough about her as a separate individual to show any significant amount of her life and communication that isn’t just interactions with or about this guy, then arguably you’re kind of working from a perspective where the woman is more a prize than a person.

Totally different. Phil is focused on improving himself. In fact, the times in the middle when he is trying to manipulate her, he fails miserably.

It’s a completely harmless and extremely common desire, something every single one of us has to have done countless times. There was zero evil about it.

It’s not harmless to change someone else to fit your desires. In real life where it can’t actually happen, perhaps you can argue it’s harmless to them. But it’s not harmless to your own psyche. That attitude keeps you focused on what others should be doing, not on what you can do to improve yourself.

If I wished that everyone who slighted me would die, it’s not going to harm them. But you wouldn’t consider me a healthy, well-adjusted person.

I do however agree with you that such wishes are extremely common, which is why this is not just about Bear.