On my mind

With apologies to my LJ friends, since I put this there, too. I’ve needed so badly to get this out of my head.

There’s something I’ve been thinking about a lot. It’s from an interview with a holocaust survivour, and I’ll be damned if I can think of or find where I read it at. Regardless, the interviewer had asked this man why so many Jews stayed in Germany when they could see for themselves what was happening. The man replied, “So many Jews have pianos. It’s hard to leave a piano behind.”

I can’t get that out of my mind.

To see what’s happening, to see your friends and your family disappear bit by bit, to see the governmental system break down and replace itself with something utterly unknown and scary and just plain wrong. To see so many people support the new system, whether through fear or through actual belief. To know it’s based upon hating you…to not be able to convince anyone of the inherent wrongness of what is happening. Helplessness.

I also think about the quintessential “war-torn nations.” I feel I have to put it in quotes, for we’ve heard the phrase so often it’s almost meaningless at this point. People that live every day not knowing if this is the day they die. We all know we can go at any point, but we don’t live with that knowledge, cheek-to-jowl. We don’t sleep with it and breathe it, eat it and dream of it. Many people in the world do. Bombs every day, going to a loved one’s house and finding the building simply gone, the utter helplessness of not being able to protect your child or your wife or your mother or your…jesus. It’s too momentous to even fully grasp. Yet they stay. More than a few can’t leave for monetary reasons, I’m sure. And more than that just simply aren’t allowed to leave. But how many stay just hunkered down, thinking it has to get better soon. Their whole lives are there, and it’s best to stay and wait and see than to leave so much behind.

Pianos.

Strange days, my friends. I think about us, as Americans. I wonder if we’re in the beginning of this. The tragedy that has befallen us and the turns our lives have taken scare me to the core of my being.
The thing that scares me most is how relieved we all are at the recent plane crash. I’m not throwing stones here, far be it from. But to be able to just write it off as “only an accident” is terrifying when you think about it. How can we walk the line between putting our strong face on and going about, just business as usual? Can we all think back for just a moment to 9/11, please? It’s so hard to do so. The absolute pit of our stomach fear. The certainty that we were going to war. The knowledge that our lives were forever changed. The Orwellian sense of unreality, not knowing for the first time in most of our lives what the world would generally be like tomorrow.

I remember Desert Storm like it was yesterday. I was in college and one of my brothers was in one of the first deployed units. I was terrified and hurt and worried, but this is different. This was right here on home turf. Those fuckers INVADED us. They killed us. They took part of our heart, but made the rest of it beat more strongly.

However.

I think a lot about leaving the States. I do, I do, I do. I think about getting that one-way flight to Australia and keeping my head down. Waiting to see what happens. I think about it every single day, yet I don’t. I wonder if we, as a nation, are on the verge of being that “war-torn nation.” If we’re looking down the barrel at being ravaged and twisted and becoming a mere shell of what we were. We’re a great nation, to be sure, but it could happen. Not quickly, no. It so seldom happens quickly. But, oh, my friends and neighbours, it could happen indeed. What if we all look back in a year or five or ten or 20 and think, “I could have gotten out while there was time. I saw the signs and I didn’t pay any attention?” What if we lose our very lives because we have blind faith?

We all have our pianos here. All of us. I can see us in our living rooms, polishing and tuning our pianos, looking at the beautiful gleam and listening to the round tones as our houses burn down around us.

I think about this. All the time.

You’ve said it far more eloquently than I could ever have.

A fine sonata, Mz Nym, and buoyed by the knowledge that you’d always be able to turn the keys of that mere piano into a sailboat, lighthouse, or ambulance as the need occured.

Bravo Nym! You’ve moved me. Now put me back where I belong and I’ll comment on the thread!

I don’t know that the one-way ticket to Australia would work though. I suspect that what happens in the US will also happen in the nations allied with the US. It’s not like prewar Germany where there were places to go if one could get out.

Quite frankly if Australia is a bastion of freedom then we’re all doomed ;). The election a fortnight ago, the dreadful, dreadful treatment of the boatpeople/refugees… geez…

getting depressed here.

Very well said. But I’m not getting out. Don’t want to turn this into a debate, but I’m more optimistic than the general tone of the above. I’m not a “What if” person. That’s negative. FWIW.

~~Nymysys, Nymysys,

I had a Nazi concentration camp survivor as a professor once…
I was more interested in what he went through than what I was
supposed to be learning so I’d ask him questions that no one
else would ask, like what he did to survive… He was a tailor
and said he sewed Nazi uniforms all through the war…

But anyway, I’m glad that most people don’t have the magnitude and flavor of
fear that you do… We’d make terrible Israelies if we
ditched our country because of bombs and killing… You know,
nationalism isn’t so bad if you wait for it to come back in style…

What the hell is “blind faith” in this case? How many Americans
is Australia prepared to take, all of us or just you?

Is it any wonder that I detect selfishness in your statement?
It has been the former lack of a threat to Americans that
cultures selfish ideas, and all of this in the comfort of
your own home, no doubt…

…so much so that it isn’t even recognized anymore…
This was satire right?

I have heard several acquaintances say that they were thinking about leaving the U.S. to live in another country.
Their reasons being political (don’t like our government - it’s corrupt and doesn’t truly represent “The People”), financial (don’t like being held down and exploited by “The Man” in a Capitalist system) or just for the fun of it. These acquaintances were looking for their “pianos” because they didn’t have them here.

I have seen what it’s like outside of the U.S. I have seen brutality, corruption, fear, distrust and all the ugliness of humanity. I have also seen beauty, hope, creativity and a desire to be better. More often than not, I have seen that people all over the world want to have what the people of the United States have.

It takes tremendous courage, a strong heart and force of will to face all the things that happen, here, in the U.S. and in the rest of the world. It’s easy to see inequity, dispair and horror. I think most of us feel a pang of guilt that we can’t stop another’s suffering. We want so desperately to help, to make a difference. We want this because of our humanity, because we want everyone to be happy, because it makes each of happy when everyone else is happy.

Fear. Being scared. It’s o.k. to be scared. That means you care, that you aren’t dead inside and that you can recognize a threat. You asked, “How can we walk the line between putting our strong face on and going about, just business as usual?” Going about “business as usual” is getting on with life. I don’t think anyone will forget 9/11 or the recent crash nor will they ever completely lose the feelings associated with them. It’s like a very close relative or friend dying. One misses them always and in thinking of the lost loved one, feels the pain of their abscence but also remembers the joy of their life. No one can run from these feelings. If one does run, it is a certainty that the feelings will follow. Because they are inside us always.

One final thing. Humans all over the world have the same needs and desires. We all want happiness, love and a warm, safe place to live. We want to be free or fear and terror. These desires may be expressed through religion, politics, art, terrorism - all of those or more. These desires are our “pianos”. We are always looking for them (or a better one!). None of us want to give them up once we have them. We worked too hard to get them. There is no guarantee that we can get another if it is given up or taken away.

If you are wondering whether or not Australia will give you your piano then you should go and find out. Sitting here, wondering and worrying, won’t answer your question. However, no matter where you go, Nymysys, you will find a piano.

I promise.

I managed to find this conversation, and I’m glad because I remember—and am haunted by—the same interview, and the story about Jews and pianos.

It’s been 24 years since your post.

I’m still trying to find out the original source or any other info.

If anybody knows anything, please contact me!
:folded_hands: