So here is what I know at this point:
Definate (or nearly):
US Women’s world Cup Team 7/19/99
Secretariat – 6/11/73
OJ Murder – 6/27/94
Nadia Comaneci 8/2/76 (from text on the web, have see to find pictures)
Mary Lou Retton: 8/13/84 (haven’t seen a pic of the newsweek)
Maybe, Maybe Not:
1980 Mens USA Hockey – (see above post)
Muhammad Ali (see above post)
Reggie Jackson (see above)
Joe Namath: Newsweek 9-15-69; Time 10-16-72; SI 1-20-69;6-16-69; 8-11-69; 8-17-70; 10-9-72 – Still possible.
Probably Not:
Boris Becker
Denny McLain
Jack Nicklaus