Andi? Just a little bit of advice, for future reference: if your enemies spend no effort to prevent you from moving in a certain direction despite having the resources to do so, that probably means that moving in that direction won’t end well for you.
I think it was Churchill who said that in a crisis, the best choice you could make was the right thing, the second-best choice you could make was the wrong thing, and the worst choice was nothing.
Bandana is either a rogue or rogue-adjacent type with at least some decent levels under her belt who works on a ship. Which makes me wonder how well tying her up is really going to work.
“My word is my bond; I fulfill every contract, and honor every promise.”
“But you’ve never given your word – or signed a contract, or made a promise.”
“Uh, yeah. After all, given how lawful I am, the alternative would be pretty stupid.”
And now that people are no longer discussing the new comic:
And that is our fundamental point of disagreement. Despite what the Deva says, I don’t see Roy doing this, especially since he died. I see Elan doing it all the time. His rules are not mechanics, and they aren’t absolutely true. And he alone follows them, and chooses to do so.
I realize that alignments are hard to change here. I like it that way myself. The only canon alignment change here is killing someone you swore an oath of fealty to. Even genocide of the Goblins race isn’t enough to make you not Lawful Good.
Still, I think that Lawful Good Roy is less lawful than Neutral Good Elan. Other than providing me with a bunch of times that Roy consciously made the choice to follow some set of rules, I don’t see that changing. Making special exceptions for Elan’s “Narrative Law” definitely won’t do it. Neither will taking something that has complex rules and trying to claim it is Chaotic.
Fortunately, I’m not your DM, so there’s no problem with me continuing to disagree with you. Heck, this crap is why I say DMs shouldn’t really enforce alignment beyond the very beginning.
He alone? We’ve met two others who follow the Narrative: Tarquin and JulioScoundrel. Three people, of three different alignments (Chaotic Good, Lawful Evil & Chaotic Neutral), who all recognize the same Narrative mechanics helping to guide their universe. And the other two are considerably more rational people than Elan.
And, given that one is a Fighter and the other a Rogue, this isn’t even a bardic thing we’re talking about.
Also, the Narrative isn’t “Chaotic” any more than physics are chaotic or, in the case of V, metaphysics are chaotic. You’re not lawful for recognizing any of them, you’re not chaotic for being ignorant of them. They just ARE. You can be Lawful, Chaotic, Good, Evil or Neutral and recognize the Narrative, just as you can be any alignment and still recognize the metaphysics of Magic.
And of course Elan went to “Bard Camp.” Wizards go to schools, fighters go through boot camp, and thieves go to the guild. But bards? They spend a summer at “Bard Camp.”
We’re not allowed to discuss politics and current events in the GitP forum, and it may not be an especially good idea here, but what the hell.
Did anyone else see a parallel between Andi’s reaction to barely making it past the mountain with probably some damage and a certain person who’s recently become a world leader? Someone who thinks they had a landslide victory when they actually squeaked out a technical win? I have no idea if this was intentional, but I can’t help but think so.
"As usual, there are no references to current politics beyond those readers invent for themselves. But hey, stop reading if it makes you feel better. "