Order of the Stick book 7 discussion thread

I’m assuming everyone knows the metaphor for Death he’s referencing. She certainly doesn’t ask for clarification.

Did Malack carry a scythe?

Just a staff, I believe.

It’s quite a bit, but if you were reading this in book form (instead of a page every 3-21 days) it probably wouldn’t bother you.

It doesn’t bother me. I was just using the length of the arc as evidence it’s going to be important later.

“Do you really think we can end this whole thing - beat Xykon and the goblins in just seven weeks?”

“No, it’s probably going to take at least fifteen years.”

But on a more serious note, re-reading that strip I see that the panel where Roy says Belkar will die soon is inset in a scene where O-Chul is threatening to kill Belkar. Is that juxtaposition foreshadowing?

Quick poll:

Do you think the Monster in the Dark is:

  • Something consistent with all of the clues, but will have no real storyline/WOW factor for non-DnD nerds
  • Something with storyline/WOW factor but will be wildly off on game mechanics
  • Threading the needle: both the storyline/WOW factor whilst remaining consistent with all the clues
  • Neither: the mechaninces will be wrong and the reveal will not have a WOW factor
0 voters

My theory is that the MitD is one of the Eastern pantheon gods. My guess is Hephaestus.

I don’t know how that works in with D&D mechanics.

Same, but I’m pretty sure he’ll have to fudge the game mechanics.

The Greeks are Eastern?

What is this “Greece” of which you speak? /Miko

Yes, the Graeco-Roman inspired gods are the Eastern Pantheon; the Babylonian inspired gods are the Western; the Norse are the Northern, and the 12 gods of Azure City are the Southern.

The Southern pantheon is based on Chinese astrology.

I know?

I didn’t mean to imply you did not. But you identified what historical culture was the source for the other three pantheons and I wanted to add in the fourth.

I think it will be consistent with all the clues, but the Wow factor won’t match the Dragon vs Dinosaur fight. It will be Wow enough for me, and a nice demonstration of Rich’s improved drawing skills. I’m not sure how broad its appeal will be.

I don’t know for sure what Monster-San is, but I will resolutely and absolutely hang my hat on this: He doesn’t originate in any D&D sourcebook. He’s probably had D&D stats published at some point, because everything has had D&D stats published at some point, but that’s not where he originated.

It’s BARNEY!!

Pfft, you SAY it’s not in D&D but obviously YOU never read 1975’s Strategic Review Vol. 1 Issue…

I assume it will be consistent with the clues but am skeptical of any WOW factor after this many years of build-up. No slight intended, just an assumed reality given the years of speculation and everything under the sun having been guessed at by now.

1312 - Poor Sleep Hygiene