On Normal Pens: My favorite is the Jimnie Gel by Zebra. Smooth write, bold line, good rich black ink. Nominally refillable, though I have a) never seen any refills in any store and b) never run one out of ink.
On Fountain Pens: I started using fountain pens because I was a tree-hugger in high school and college, and I liked the idea of refilling them. In practice, since I was buying cheap pens with no adapters, I went through so many cartridges that I was not doing Mother Earth any Favors–should have just used refillable ballpoints.
Nonetheless, there is a mystique associated with fountain pens. I spent many hours nursing cheap, balky pens, getting inky fingers, rewriting smeared pages, and loving every minute of it. There are a small number of rational reasons to like them. They feel different from normal pens–whether they feel better is an individual preference, but I prefer the feel of a fountain pen. Even cheap ones are more expressive than just about any other pen. (Expressiveness means that the width of the line varies with the pressure you apply.) You can get all sorts of nifty keen colors of ink. (These days, with gel pens in any ridiculous color you can imagine, this isn’t such a big deal, but when I was in college, if you wanted cool colors, the best you could hope for was to find a green ballpoint.) And there’s a certain air of sophistication. Many people admire fountain pens and will be impressed to see you using one. Some people don’t even know how to write with a fountain pen. A few times I’ve loaned one out only to watch in horror as the writer attempted to write with the top of the nib.
But really, I like them 'cause I like them. That’s all there is to it.
Eventually, I was given a good Shaeffer as a gift, and then I learned the joy of heft. The feel of a good, solid pen in your hand is not to be underestimated. For some reason, a big o’ heavy rollerball just feels . . . clunky. A nice, hefty fountain pen with good balance delivers the weight on the nib and drives your writing forward. (If you’re not sure whether your pen was designed with balance in mind, try writing without putting the cap on the end. On a good pen, it will feel totally wrong.)
I have long since lost that Shaeffer. sob I can only hope that it was found by someone who appreciates fountain pens.
Freiheit, try out a cheap fountain pen and see if you like it. Do not get a cheap Shaeffer. If you want to spring for a good Shaeffer, be my guest! But in my experience, the cheap ones are leaky, globby, and altogether a pain in the ass. Some good cheap brands that are widely available are Parker, Diplomat, or A&W. Levenger (www.levenger.com) is also now carrying lots of pens in the <$20 range.