Planning Caribbean vacation

So four of us want to go to somewhere in the Caribbean at the end of March. Searching the web seems to bring lots of repeats, maybe four or five hotels per location. while I know there must be a TON of hotels, time-shares renting out, etc. Where is the best web location to find something somewhat unique and at the same time not really expensive.

You’re looking for informed opinions here, so I’ve taken the liberty of moving the thread to IMHO from General Questions, which is for questions with factual answers.

samclem GQ moderator