Please help me resolve this problem

For over a year now I have been facing the prospect of having to make a very important decision. I’ve been postponing and postponing it, but now I’ve reached the point where I have to make a choice. This decision will have a large impact on my life; it will directly influence the next three to five years, and may even have repercussions beyond that. Part of the problem of not being able to make a decision was that I was having serious financial problems lately, and it’s my firm belief that any important decision should not be made when you’re in a funk. These financial problems are not quite over yet, but their urgency is gone and hopefully in a couple of months I’ll be able to look back and not get a headache any more. But now I’m reaching the point where any further postponement of that decision may have even more serious consequences.

As always I approached my decision-making with my usual analysis. I know this is professional deformation (I’m a systems analyst), but it’s how I do these things. And the weird part was, I came up with distinct choices. No grey areas, no overlappings. As proof that real life is not about black & white decisions, my list of possible choices contained nine scenarios. Granted, some of these scenarios are similar in one respect or other, but they are distinct nonetheless. Since these scenarios contained all possible choices, I was able to mark six of them as non-viable. These six scenarios would either leave me with regrets in the long term, have (nearly) immediate serious consequences or even would be impossible for me to live with. So then there were three.

I’ve gone over them and gone over them and now have given them a kind of grade; which solution seems the most preferable to me, which is next and which is last. I know I really should talk this over with someone, or even some people, but that’s something I have a lot of problems with. I tried to get the subject started with my best friend, but this particular problem is something he has no experience with whatsoever. I thought about talking this over with my parents and/or sister, but I didn’t want to burden them with my problems. I know they have been worrying about my financial troubles, and this they can do without. I’ve been on the SDMB only for a little while now, but I saw this as a possible solution. It may seem strange to present such an important decision to people I have never even met, but from what I have read from the various discussions I know that most of the people here are very well informed, and are perfectly able to make a judgement call. The fact that I have a good degree of anonymity because of the use of a screen name makes it a little easier for me to come to you with such a personal question. And it’s not that I want to walk away from my responsibility; any decision I make will ultimately be mine. It’s more that I would like to hear from you what you think the consequences of any scenario could be. There’s always the possibility that I have overlooked an aspect of the decision I’m about to make.

I want to thank everyone in advance for taking the time to read this. I’ll present the problem and the scenarios for a solution below, and I will be most grateful for any input you’ll be able to give me. During the holidays I will probably come to a decision, seeing as this is the season for introspection. I will think about letting you all know this decision, but because of the personal nature of my plight I might do this on a person to person basis, rather than posting it this way.

Thanks,

Hans (SkinnyGuy)

So, the big question and its possible answers. Should I get a grey, a black or a beige Toyota Avensis?

Grey: It’s snazzy looking.

Besides, the black’ll show dirt too easily (you wanna be running to a carwash every 3 days?) and the beige is just…too…y’know…beige. Unless you’re a post-middle-aged crisis guy who wants to make a statement about how stable his life is. And, well…the beige is just blah.

Fenris

Personally, I like the black. Yes, it gets dirtier easier (I own a black car), but I’ve never minded too much. Definitely not beige.

Hey! You said no grey areas! Doesn’t that eliminate choice 1?

I think your real problem is nomenclature. Who wants a beige car? But call it “gold” or “bronze” and it sounds a bit better.

I’d go with grey or beige. Black is just too hard to see at night. And if you live in the snow belt, grey doesn’t really stand out on those nasty, sleety, misty days when on the whole, you’d rather people knew you were on the road. But I think grey is kind of a classy color for a car.

Gray says “I can’t make up my mind.” and beige says “I’m a dweeb”, so black it is.

Of course, it’s a 4 door, so maybe beige is more fitting…

Get a red one, man! They go faster!

That’s the choice I couldn’t live with. White and blue I’d regret right away, green I’d come to regret, but red is a definite no-no.

I have solemnly vowed NEVER to own a red car, NEVER to own a stationwagon and NEVER to own a Volkswagen. So if you ever see me coming down the road in a red VW Golf or Passat or Whatever stationwagon, you know the Body Snatchers have gotten to me.

Brother Fenris: Grey is my first choice. But the black one is sooo stylish. The problem is of course that I’m not a 3-day carwash guy. I’m not even a 3-month carwash guy…

ArchiveGuy (no relation) & Finagle & Just About Everybody Else: what’s wrong with beige? (It’s the “official” Toyota name: Sparkling Beige.) Since a car is supposed to be an extension of your, um, organ anyway, I don’t need to go for a macho colour. I can, you know, show my sensitive, caring feminine side as I force you off the road.

I vote for grey. It just . . . feels right.

I read that whole damn OP just to find out you are to indecisive to pick out the color of a car?
Frick, Frick, Frick!!

Get the black one.

Osip

your still a :wally
skinnyguy.

You would come to regret green!?!?!?!?!?!?!
[sub] and here I was thinking you were cool[/sub]

Out of your choices (given that you have excluded green) my vote is for black.

[sub] Sorry to be so harsh, but green cars just do something to me. I adore them. My car is this deep shiny green that just makes me happy to have it around. Green is such a wonderful car color. Sigh. [/sub]

That notwithstanding, I would go with either the beige (call it gold) or grey. Having worked in an automobile detail shop, I can tell you that if you even look at a black car wrong, it will scratch. And black cars are extremely hot in the summer. Other than that, black cars are beautiful.

my 2.3547689 cents worth. :smiley:

Well, I don’t know about the red car, and I actually agree with you on VW’s, but just wait until you buy a house and have to stand outside the lumberyard in a freezing drizzle tying 2x4’s to the top of your car while the guy in the station wagon tosses them in the back and drives off. You might rethink your stand on station wagons. You also save a bundle on bike and ski carriers. And if you toss a canoe or kayak on top, you lose a lot of the stodgy stigma associated with station wagons.

Nowadays, the 4-wheel drive station wagon sends the signal: “I’m a studly sort of guy who does so much cool stuff that I can’t fit all the equipment in a sedan, but I care enough for the environment that I refuse to buy some bloated gas guzzling ecological disaster of an SUV.” Although I reluctantly admit that in my limited experience, attractive ladies don’t appear to be equipped to actually receive this signal. Maybe I should have gotten the red…

After reviewing the pictures, I say go for the black. It looks the most sophisticated. Let us know what you decide.

If you have grey hair, get the gray one, black hair, the black one etc. Chicks dig coordination. If you’re gay, try the purple one.

aaaaaaaaagh.

All that build-up for a car colour!? Personally I would pick red or white. But if you must; go with grey…it’s classy and practical.

And I’m with you, Skinnyguy: I would NEVER (again) own a volkswagen. I can never, ever forgive them for the bug I used to own as long as I live. But I do like red cars, and station wagons can be cool if you have the right bumper stickers on them.

What’s wrong with blue? I have a really pretty dark blue Saturn.

Given the choices HERE, I’d probably go with grey. Beige…ick. My mom had a beige Escort for a while and the car ran fine, but it sure was ugly.

Hey, some of the new station wagons are decent-looking, not the big boxy “I’m taking the kids to baseball/soccer practice”.

After years of struggling trying to cram camping equipment into a two-door sedan and trunk, I got smart and bought a wagon. And believe me, like Finagle stated, the trips to the lumber store are much easier now, as well as grocery shopping excursions.

My mistake was getting a white one. Choice among black, weird shade of green, and white, but I would have gone with blue if it was available.

My opinion: go for the gray.

(My sister has a Mercedes [bought from an auto auction, repaired and fixed it up herself] - it’s filing-cabinet beige, nicknamed “Bland”.)

I had a job working for Clint Eastwood’s wife Maggie in PB. Maggie’s car (mecedez), clothes & makeup were all coordinated. It was kinda fun.

Personally, I like the NEW nomenclature for beige: “Champagne”!

…makes even a Ford Festiva look high-society!
Oh, and Medea’s Child? I agree w/you re: the whole green thing. I may be painting myself as a trend-sheep, but the best looking cars come in what, IIRC, is referred to as BRG (British Racing Green).

Ditto on the green. I love that dark metalic forest green that varies between almost black and lovely glittery green depending on the light.
Picked that for my car - 'nelle approved of it.

Black, beige or grey?
Bleah.
But to make the best of three pathetic colors, a platinum or grey colored car.