This is a fun category - I’ve been looking up the other usual suspects to see where they fell short. Rickey Henderson had the total hits, but moved around too much, and didn’t get much accumulation outside of NY or Oakland. Same with Pete Rose. Ichiro, Boggs and Griffey only had 2 teams with 500, and a small amount in a 3rd, let alone a 4th.
Not a question, but an interesting fact I just learned.
On August 11, 2015, there was a full slate of MLB games, so 15 in all. The home team won every game, 15-0. That is the only time that has ever happened on a day when every team played in the expansion era.
What major league pitcher went 207-126 lifetime, was a key part of World Series-winning teams for two different clubs, and had five 20+ win seasons, but was never seriously considered for the Hall of Fame?
Carl Mays, one of the best pitchers of the late dead ball and early “live” ball eras, with stats equivalent to or better than contemporaries who ended up in the Hall of Fame. Even if he hadn’t thrown the pitch that killed Ray Chapman, he was regarded as the most disliked player of his time (quite an accomplishment, since his career substantially overlapped that of Ty Cobb), and was accused by a sportswriter of throwing a 1921 World Series game (never proven).
Yes you want to qualify the question in some way such as “player with sufficient plate appearances to qualify for batting title” I’m sure there are many players with just a few at bats each season who do’nt ground into double plays.