Previous owners mail getting mail, but I'm also listed as sending address

My SO and I bought a house a year ago. The previous owners were a church, which used the house as both a parsonage and as the regional church offices. The house had been vacant for 2 years before we moved in.
So we’re getting mail for the old occupants, both the family that lived here, and the church offices. No biggie. “Return to sender, no longer at this address.”

This weekend, we got a new twist. A preprinted address, with the church name and our address as both the sender and the recipient. This had obviously been through the post office several times. It had 3 of the yellow forwarding stickers on it. There was handwriting all over it, and finally someone had circled the return address and stuck it in our mailbox.

I have no contact info for the previous owners. All forwarding services from the post office have apparently expired, and there is no place to return it to, since my address is listed as the return address.

So what’s my obligation concerning this piece of mail? (Yes, I know, I’ll be checking with the postmaster, when I get a chance. But that may be 2 weeks.)

write on it very clearly that you are not the originator of the mail, the people named XXXX Church were apparently the originator of the mail, and you are not them. Request that it go to the dead letter office to be opened and the contents handled appropriately.

Excellent idea. I had forgotten that the Dead Letter Office even exists.

*My new house
You should see my house
My new house
You should see my new house

No rabbit hutch about it
I bought it off the baptists
I get the bills
And I get miffed*

from *My New House *by The Fall

:smiley:

As far as I’m concerned, my obligations, after a year of residence, goes no further than to glance at the letter to ascertain if it is a critically important message before recycling it. If it appears important, I’ll write “no longer at this address” and it’s back in the mailbox. If it comes back again, it’s gone.