New report says that microwaving plastics release zillions of microplastic and nanoplastic particles:
Discourse, for once, gives previous threads that were actually relevant to this topic. There were several from way back in the early days about how plastic in microwaves may be producing dioxins. One example:
Anyway, the bottom line is: don’t microwave food in plastic containers!
If you read the article, it goes on to say we probably shouldn’t be putting food in plastic containers at all. Microwaving them certainly makes it worse, but the problem isn’t the “microwave” part. It’s the “plastic” part.
What substance are they talking about? “Plastic” isn’t a substance. It’s a broad category of a great many different substances, with a similar variety of chemical and physical properties. Any study that just talks about “plastic” is completely useless.
I read that a few days ago. There’s a certain amount of science behind it, but also some politics.
The whole point is simply that artificial long-chain hydrocarbon polymers are unlikely to be biologically inert, and especially not down at nano-particle sizes. And we’re flooding the planet, and us, and all other living critters, with them.
The study cited by the article goes into some detail about what they’re talking about.
So I’m no big fan of plastics per se but boy, the potential risks seem to have a level of evidence behind them that makes the artificial sweeteners data look strong.
To the degree these particles do end up to be significant health risks … and they may or may not be … I am not so clear how much more potential risk is posed by reheating the leftovers over storing them in the containers in the first place. Bottled water seems like a big possible source too, especially as they may have transported in hot trucks and stored in hot warehouses.
Understood better to use refillable non plastic water bottles, to store in glass or ceramic containers, and reheat in the metal pan on a not gas stove. Less landfill less emissions beyond health risk.
But from this hard to know where to place this possible risk on the scale.
I’ve always been concerned about plastic in the microwave.
But I worry about, really too much. Mid-dau is always saying “it says it’s microwave safe”
Is anything really safe?
Should we even have microwaves in the home?
What about bleach?
And all those cel phone emissions boring into my brain!
Aaaccckkk!
Excuse me, I’ll be in the closet chewing my cuticles.
From the abstract, because I don’t have access to the full report,
Exposure modeling results suggested that the highest estimated daily intake was 20.3 ng/kg·day for infants drinking microwaved water and 22.1 ng/kg·day for toddlers consuming microwaved dairy products from polypropylene containers. Furthermore, an in vitro study conducted to assess the cell viability showed that the extracted microplastics and nanoplastics released from the plastic container can cause the death of 76.70 and 77.18% of human embryonic kidney cells (HEK293T) at 1000 μg/mL concentration after exposure of 48 and 72 h, respectively.
Why test at a 1000 μg/mL concentration, which is over 4,000 times the highest estimated daily exposure?
One: you can’t translate a dose per kg/day to amount per ml easily.
But beyond that higher concentrations to kidney actually has some logic albeit I don’t know about the exact multiple: the kidney filters and concentrates, exposing kidney cells to much higher concentrations than serum levels, especially over time if they accumulate, as seems to be the case.
Again there are plenty of decent reasons for us to all limit our purchase and use of plastic products, in ways that do not cause undue burden. Avoiding heating in plastic containers is not a big deal thing. Maybe I’ll try to do better and certainly would do better if feeding a pregnant women or a young child.
On balance is it better for the world to get baby food in glass or plastic based containers? I dunno.
But right now the risk of micro plastics at typical exposures is unknown and unproven. Even if “probable” is a fair descriptor. On the list of items that make me assume fetal position it is pretty low.