Pulp Fiction: a theory

We don’t know. Like Jules, we only see the miracle itself. We have to figure out its meaning. Perhaps Mia, while the central figure in the events of the movie, has only a supporting role in some larger as-yet-unseen story.

Samuel L. Jackson has such a presence that he fools people into thinking Jules is a central character. But consider that when Jules and Vincent are apart, the story follows Vincent. Jules is just a supporting character to Vincent. And Vincent doesn’t have any story - he lives and then he dies. It’s obviously not Vincent’s story so he must also be a supporting character.

Consider the other character the story follows: Butch. In a parallel to what happened with Vincent, we follow Butch through the movie for a while. But once he’s saved a life (Marsellus’s) he hops on a motorcycle and rides out of the movie. Like Vincent, Butch has fulfilled his role.

Hey, consider the opening scene: Tim Roth is planning a heist – and then we get the rest of the film, showing us the story of a bunch of other people, before coming back around to show us how and why that crook got shown the error of his ways!

That’s what I figured too. Marvin swapped out the bullets and forgot to mention it to Jules and Vincent before his, er, accident.

Except, it’s been a while, but I distinctly remember bullet holes all over the place after the miraculous shooting.

I’m not sure if it’s intentional or not, but you can actually see one of the bullet holes over Jules’ shoulder just before he starts shooting.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XSmqxPuF-Xk

Chill the fuck out, guys, this shit happens.

There is evidence that this is true. The bullet holes in the wall were there before the shooting started.

Only some of the bullets holes are there, although you can see the patches that are over some of them. Could be Tarantino winking at us, could be imperfect continuity.
As far as the scene goes, I think the whole flock of seagulls were in over there heads, and he just didn’t know how to handle the weapon.

Much more than that: Butch, who really is kind of a low-life, has been tested, tried, and redeemed.

First, he fucks Marsellus over royally by taking his money and not throwing the boxing match as he had agreed to do (he actually KILLS his opponent and feels not one shred of remorse).

He took all of the money Marsellus gave him and bet it on himself to win, showing that the above was no accident but a thoroughly premeditated scam.

He knows he has to get out of town fast, but is forced to go home for his father’s watch. While there, he whacks Marsellus’s own hit man (Vincent, who was given the chance to repent but ignored it and, like a true Elvis fan, dies on/in the toilet).

Finally, after a Psycho-like moment when he spies his former boss through the windscreen of his automobile, he all but offs Marsellus himself, but is stopped at the last second by a perverted redneck.

He manages to escape from the Deliverance-type situation they’ve landed in (a true circle of Hell), but the words of Capt. Koons come back to him from his dream (“two men in a bad situation have to take responsibility for each other”), and he can’t find it in his heart to abandon Marsellus.

He goes back and rescues him, which he emphatically does NOT have to do: he could just have kept on walking out and no one would be any the wiser. That actually would have been the smart thing to do, as he’s still on Marsellus’s shit-list.

In the end, he’s pardoned by Marsellus (who is kind of a God-like figure since, as one of my students once pointed out, he’s the one character around whom all the others revolve) and rides off into the sunset on (wait for it!) Grace.

Epiphany, Repentance (of a sort), Redemption, and Grace; verily, he hath found favor in the eyes of the Lord!

Great. A god leap into one of my favorite movies to ruin it. I suppose this is the same reason Luke fired the photons into the exhaust vent without his targeting computer.

No, he was symbolicly fertilizing the Death Star/Ovum. I dare you to unread that.

Yes it was. Vincent offers a perfectly acceptable ‘explanation’: they got lucky. There’s really no need for your theory.

I have no idea what you mean. That scene was pure movie magic. If you’re implying it was medically inaccurate and therefore lame, I can’t argue, but don’t agree.

Vincent goes to the bathroom three times in this movie, and every time he does something really bad happens.

I do not know the significance of this.

Okay - where did that come from?!

And shouldn’t there be a [brain bleach] code you should be required to employ for something like that?

That wasn’t magic or God, that was bacteria in his bloodstream.

Hockey. In the end, it was all about inspiring young men to play hockey.

Interesting how they bleeped it out when he said bitch but didn’t when he said son of a bitch.

Everything bad comes in threes. :mad:

Let’s face it: the whole movie is a religious allegory filled with betrayal, a massacre of innocents, divine intervention, death, a God-like figure, a Jesus figure, resurrection, epiphany, circles of Hell, repentance, redemption, and grace.

Its structure gives the audience a God’s-eye view of the story by flashing back and forth through time while providing continuity markers.

Put the segments into chronological order and the focus of the movie becomes Jules’s conversion and what happens to Vincent when he refuses to believe, like the two thieves at Calvary.