Questions about a structured settlement-- what do you think?

So. Here’s the situation, and I’ll try to explain it as clearly as possible (the attempt will be made, anyway, and please tell me if it doesn’t make sense!) Many years ago, I was in a horrible accident as a young teenager and got a personal injury settlement (for, well, permanent injuries.) Half of it was a lump sum–and my financial advisor has told me that I’m one of the VERY few people he’s ever seen who had any amount as a lump sum and didn’t just blow through it all in a few years (or ten years. Or twenty years!) Most of the other half was basically set up as a regular structured settlement with small amounts every month.

However, there was also a third part. The best way I can describe it is that this was set up in the framework of a pension type of thing. I would get one lump sum at a certain time (many years later),and another lump sum ten years after that. The first lump sum is now set to be due in four years. So here’s what we have.

1.) Structured settlement every month, will last for life, but not a lot of money.
2.) Original lump sum, quite a bit of it is still there but with medical expenses to meet I don’t think I should count on it for a 20% down payment.
3.) Lump sum payout #1 in four years ($235,000)
4.) Lump sum payout #2 in 14 years ($475,000)
5.) None of it is/was/will be taxable.

But here’s the problem. I live in Portland (OR), and I’ve found the perfect neighborhood that hasn’t YET been taken over by yuppies. This means that housing prices aren’t bad at all right now, but they could easily explode into total insanity soon. PDX has to be one of the worst places in America for that right now; all of California is moving here and rents are often 2-5 times what they were less than five years ago. MANY neighborhoods have seen house prices doubling, tripling, and quadrupling in less than five years. Ardenwald has got to be one of the next neighborhoods to go-- it’s across a major street from a neighborhood that the same thing happened to in the past year (house prices and rent prices doubling in a year, and that is not an exaggeration.) We also have a MAX line that will open this fall about two blocks from my house.

Basically, I can see the writing on the wall. If I wait four years to buy, I would not be at all surprised to see prices two, three, four, or even five times what they are now (because this has happened in many of the close-in neighborhoods. I’ve seen it over and over again, and so have all of my friends. I am really not kidding. I personally know people who sold their houses for about $200,000, a developer renovated them, and they were next sold for $1.1 million.) BUT, if I can buy within about a year, I think I can beat the truly insane rise in prices. Because it really could happen where I live now.

So here’s the question. Would it be worth it to find a way to sell the first lump sum annuity (not the second one)? And what’s the best way to do it? Has anybody else done this? It’s a little unusual-- it’s not exactly the same as a “structured settlement”, because it was set up to be a lump sum payment at a particular time from the very start. It’s appreciated ever since then, and after about twenty-five years, it only has four years to go. You can never know exactly what will happen, but buying in, say, a year as opposed to four years could save literally hundreds of thousands of dollars on the price of a house. There were MUCH more dramatic price increases that actually happened in several central neighborhoods over the last five years. It’s not unrealistic at all that it could happen in my neighborhood (where I’m currently renting a house.)

Thoughts? Comments? Advice? Musings? And thanks for making it through this whole rambling thought process! :slight_smile:

Since the OP is asking for advice, let’s move this to IMHO.

Colibri
General Questions Moderator

You’re essentially asking us whether you should take the chance that you will not need that first lump sum payout for your health expenses in the immediate term, in order to buy an asset that you think is likely to jump in value. We don’t know your risk tolerance or the details of your health situation (and I’m not asking you to disclose anything), and most of us won’t be able to gauge how accurate your assessment of the Portland market might be, so I think it’s going to be hard for any of us to give you meaningful guidance.

If you do opt to pursue the house: I tend to think that the companies that buy structured settlements usually do so at a ruinous discount, because they are typically dealing with people who need money fast. You might actually be better off buying with a much smaller down payment and paying PMI for a couple of years, until you receive the lump sum and can pay down the mortgage to the point where your equity reaches 20 percent.

Why do you need to “sell” your future lump sum payment of $235k, today? You would probably get a terrible discount rate as most firms that purchase these types of annuities make a lot of money off people that think they need the cash now.

Why not just approach a bank to borrow the money needed to buy the home you want. They will finance it with an appropriate market rate for a 30 year mortgage. Use your current savings from your initial lump sum payment and your monthly annuity, to make your monthly payments for the next four years, then when your $235k payment comes, then payoff your mortgage if you want to.

First post nailed it.

If your guess is correct, can you find a suitable house and make enough of a down payment to get a short term (4 years) loan?

Before you say “NO” - there are expensive mortgages out there for those who really want them.
Traditional lenders look at income. These folks generally want you to have enough equity to make it profitable if they have to foreclose and sell at a discount. But don’t say ‘Can’t afford’ until you talk to them. Hint: APR is 10-12%.

This is actually a more common question than you would think! To answer your question, you honestly just have to use your best judgement as far as the housing market goes. In regards to selling your annuity lump sums, the farther out they are, the less money you’re going to receive today.

My advice would be to figure out how much you need for a down payment and sell a portion of the annuity to satisfy that amount. You don’t have to sell the whole thing.

I freelance write/blog for several different annuity companies. I could definitely help you get a quote on how to utilize your nearer lump sum and not touch the later one.

Eva

Do you have a source of income aside from the settlement money you’ve already received?