From Another Board,…
Shots from Seven Swords.
After yesterdays mad enthusiasm, I’m almost afraid to report that while the longer 153-minute version of* Seven Swords *was a far better produced DVD than the 115-version I saw earlier, I am still a bit disappointed in the movie. The transfer was much clean, brighter and more colorful than 115-minute cheapie I got earlier, which looked like a transfer from video, and was over dark. While the sutitles were far better, overall, there were places where I preferred the spotty translations on the 115 minute version. The subtitles on the longer edition took some of the bite out of the dialoge. LInes like “If you and your soldiers don’t clear out, don’t blame me for my cruelty”, became, “If you and your soldiers don’t clear out, I won’t be responsible for the consequences”. Stuff like that…
Shots from The Blade.
I suspect I was hoping for too much. I was hoping either for another genre deconstruction like Tsui Hark’s earlier film, The Blade. or something like Musa the Warrior, a more conventional, equally rousing ensemble adventure punctuated by long scenes of carnage as men hurl themselves at each other with heavy bladed weapons. While Seven Swords features much dramatically lit, beautifully framed shots of men at war, and the actors do what they can with the script, the story lacks depth, and was a bit disjointed (which still, may have been the result of cuts from the four hour original, though it was nowhere near as bad as the 115 minute version).
Set as it was in North West China, the film also has the look of a John Ford western. I kept expecting to see a chinese version of Bonanza’s Cartwrights show up in some scenes. The actor playing the villain, Fire-Wind is clearly having a ball. His performance is great fun, and the martial arts action is fun as ever, though it’s edited in a choppier style than usual for Tsui Hark. It was novel to see Donny Yen play a very Wolverine-ish Korean swordsman (I guess, after Musa, Koreans will now be typecast in Chinese film as alternatively badass, or utterly fatalistic, slaves. Another such character is due to play a major role in the Chinese film, The Promise, due out in December) and an old man, played by Lau kar-Leung, a verteran fight choreographer actually apply a judo-style throw on a horse, tossing it like a lariat across a river.
It’s also hard to believe that the story of this film comprises only the first chapter of the novel, Seven Swords of Mt. Tian upon which it is based, and that this group of swordsmens’ adventures continues on for multiple volumes. This must have originally been a serialized novel like Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon. The story of that film is based on the third or fourth volume of a five volume novel.
I guess for me, the jury is still out on this film, at least until I see the director’s four hour version, which hopefully will fill out the personalities of some of the seemingly neglected characters (like the two younger swordsmen) and the old man’s past when FireWind was his protege.
Oh BTW - for those who are into martial arts films, Tsui Hark is probably best known for his collaborations with Jet Li back in the mid-90’s, notably the first, second, third and sixth films in the Once Upon a Time in China series, wherein Jet Li played the famous Catonese folk hero and traditional chinese medicine doctor and historical figure in the development of Hung Gar Kung Fu, Wong Fei Hung.
Shots from Once Upon a Time in China I and II.
One of the most anticipated martial arts/crime dramas to come out of Hong Kong in some time, is Sha Po Lang, opened to rave reviews at the 2005 Toronto Film Festival where it was hailed as the second coming of 90’s style HK “heroic Bloodshed” cinema, a movement most closely associated to John Woo’s films of that era, most notably A Better Tommorrow I and II, Bullet in the Head, The Killer and Hard Boiled. I saw it when it screened at the AFI Los Angeles Film Festival.
… I left the theatre with very mixed feelings, and as such, felt obliged to pass along a slight warning. SPL’s spare script calls for, in fact, really demands, A-List talents like Leung (either one), Wong, Chow, Tseng, to work. I am sure Yam, Yen, Hung and Wu gave their best as actors, but they really weren’t up to the dramatic demands of the script. As a result, the first half of the film is slow going.
I have a strong suspicion that the script was originally crafted to emulate Andrew Lau’s big hit, Infernal Affairs (with the right cast, it might just have done as well) but that somewhere during pre-production the producers decided to make it a martial arts movie. In that case they didn’t go far enough. The movie needed at least two more fight scenes. (And they would have been relatively inexpensive to add: for instance, Jacky Wu Jing’s victims, both hardass cops, didn’t have to go down so easily.)
As it is, the marriage between actioneur and kung fu film is an uneasy one at best. Still, for the martial arts fan, the chance to see a well shot and edited smack down between Wu and Yen (knife vs. baton), and later between Yen and Hung (including some innovative, for HK film, inclusion of jujitsu techniques), should be worth the price of admission. I would caution anyone to rent it, or watch it in a theatre, and make up their own mind before deciding to buy the DVD however. The fusion between the two genres just isn’t that successful, in my humble opinion.
A quick warning for my fellow martial arts film fans:
Regarding the new HK cop drama/kung fu film Sha Po Lang: if you’re interested in this film, beware, there is a pirate edition out, where the final fight scene between Sammo Hung and Donnie Yen was cut short. This is most likely a sanitized version of the film intended for audiences on the Mainland, Malaysia and Singapore, places where there is still serious censorhip.
Avoid the “Mainland cut” - wait for the official HK release.
A promising looking Korean Wuxia (martial chivalry genre, of which Hero and Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon are the best known examples), Shadowless Sword opened in Korea, a month or so ago, and is scheduled for a big US release sometime in 2006. It’s about a Swordswoman who is saddled with protecting a runaway/outcast (not quite sure which) young prince from assassins during the decline of the Pakchae dynasty in ancient Korea. Critical response in Korea was mixed, a lot of people apparently kept comparing it to Chinese Wuxia and castigated it for not being “korean” enough, whatever the hell that means. I’m figuring it would do okay, if not better here, with the same crowd that liked “House of Flying Daggers”.
Interesting enough, Yoon So-Yi, who plays the swordswoman, gave a swordfighting demonstration at a promotional press event for the film.
Available on Region I DVD as part of a series of chinese film classics, He Ping’s 1990 film, Swordsmen in/of Double Flag Town is one of the purest, simplest, swordsman dramas I’ve ever seen.
It’s the story about the young son of a fallen swordsman, who travels to Double Flag Town in NW China to claim his arranged bride, a young girl whose father is the local pub/restaurant keeper, and a former swordsman in his own right. The town however is beset by marauding adult swordsmen who are a dispicable lot in and of themselves, one of whom attempts to rape the innkeepers daughter. The boy manages to kill him, setting in motion an ineveitable showdown with the would be rapists brother, one of the most dangerous swordsmen around.
In style, Swordsmen in/of Double Flag Town a lot like Sergio Leone’s work, and in story, it’s akin to the classic american western, High Noon. There isn’t much here in the way of fight scenes (and what there are, are over quick). Instead He Ping puts the emphasis on slow boil but effective suspense, and a not entirely unsympathetic look at life on the chinese western frontier. It’s def. worth a look: this has to be the cleanest, rawest look at the most basic themes of martial arts films ever made… and with the right frame of mind, can be pretty rewarding.
References:
http://www.prcmovie.com/library/swordsmen.html
http://www.filmbug.com/db/36507
http://www.facets.org/asticat?function=buy…s&catnum=/79774
http://www.lcsd.gov.hk/en/ppr_release_det…=20041015&ps=03
Information on American Release. There are trailers out there. Google’em.
http://www.twitchfilm.net/archives/004170.html#more