In period literature, people drink a hot drink called "chocolate:–not “hot chocolate”–almost, I always had the impression, as an alternative to tea or coffee. This makes me wonder if it was brewed on the stove from ground cacao beans. Does anyone know more about this early European use of chocolate, or even perhaps a recipe?
[Annie Gray, Katharine Boardman, Peter Drake and Lesley Johansen-Salter, University of York, UK ‘Sensing the Past: Recreating an Eighteenth Century Chocolate Beverage Recipe’
Archaeologists have many strategies for understanding the previous cultures, but often this excludes any attempt to experience sensations from the past. This paper explains the 18th-century context of chocolate consumption and, through an original 18th-century recipe, offers the audience a chance to experience the sensation of tasting a chocolate drink. Though we are brought up within our 21st-century culinary culture, we can appreciate the impact of the introduction of hot beverages through this simple form of experimental archaeology. The ‘otherness’ of 18th-century beverage consumption can be appreciated intellectually, but the direct sensation of a contemporary concoction emphasises this most effectively.](http://www.shef.ac.uk/archaeology/conf/dining/abstracts.html)
And Chronos, most pre-1650 recipes that are meant to be served hot tend to include the instruction “and serve it forth all hote” or something like that. If no recipes had such instruction (or if it was even a very_rare instruction, for example: the addition of salt) I would agree with you. But the serve-it-hot instruction appears just often enough to make me believe that hot beverages were the comfort of Victorians, rather than renaissance-era people.