Replacing a sliding glass door

Our doorwall is an older aluminum framed model that we’ve been contemplating replacing for energy efficiency. This was slated to wait for another year or so until we take care of more pressing financial matters, but my teenaged moosechild accidentally put himself through the door this weekend.

Good news: safety glass works!

Bad news: I’ve got to come up with the money much sooner than expected.

After a few estimates, I’m confused. I don’t mind the look of vinyl, one company is swearing real 100% vinyl is the only way to go and all composite blends are inferior while another is touting the recycled nature and steel-reinforced durability of blended vinyl. One salesperson couldn’t believe we’d consider vinyl if we’re staying more than ten years, since wood and aluminum will hold hold up ten times longer than vinyl and look better.

I know zip diddly about this stuff, except that all three contradictory opinions were offered most straightforwardly, what’s the straight dope?

No knowledge of the virtues of any of them - just posting to suggest french doors. I like the look much more. Give them a thought.

The actual door choice depends on many factors, including how much money you want to spend. A vinyl door generally costs less than a wood door. A basic Anderson vinyl door starts somewhere around $1200 (where I live) and goes up from there. A vinyl/wood combination costs more and an all wood door is usually more expensive yet.

If the door exits out to an area that is damp/shady or gets a lot of splashback from water coming off the roof then wood might not be a good replacement. Pets and children can be hard on a wood door as well.

Every salesperson is going to recommend what they have and trash the other brands…it is their JOB to sell their door, not the competitors. If you have friends/neighbors who have sliders ask them about what they have and how they feel about them. Research online (like what you are doing here) to find answers. If you have access to a Lumber Yard where they sell various models and styles don’t be afraid to ask them what might be best for you. (Big Box stores might NOT be the place for competent information)