Rhetorical question

Scotticher said:

Your musical taste is superb, ma’am.

(One of these days I’ll have to tell you about my novel. It’s serious, mostly…but I have a character called “Cotton Jenny.” She grew up in a house on a hill by a worn-down weathered old mill…and sometimes it seems her life is like a paperback novel, the kind the drugstores sell…)

I’ve never seen GL in concert, but I did get to see JB at Penn State. I almost saw SN at the New York State Fair once, but she got sick and cancelled.

I need a map…

Go Ms!

Rachmaninoff: Symphony #2 (Ashkenazy/Concertgebouw Orch.)
Verdi: Requiem (2 disks) (Solti/Vienna Philharmonic)

And I’d smuggle in Beatles: Sgt. Pepper

Well, the thought of listening to one CD from beginning to end bores me so the thought of listening to three CDs over and over again makes me want to explode my eardrums.

I would select whichever CDs I can find that are the shiniest for use as signalling mirrors and the CD player which has the best chance of being turned into a satellite phone with the judicious use of palm fronds and octopus ink.

I would have to take at least one that I had never heard before, maybe Miles Davis’s Sketches of Spain but there is so much I would hate to end up stranded on an island without ever hearing. :frowning: As far as albums I’ve already heard are concerned, Mardi Gras Mambo by Cubanismo is incredible, I just got it Friday night and haven’t gotten tired of listening to it yet.

If I am ever on a boat that sinks near a deserted island, and I am among the group of survivors who makes it to the island, I hope you will be there too.

K. This be hard, but…

  1. AEnima, TOOL

  2. Through the Past Darkly, Rolling Stones

  3. Dark Side of the Moon, (If you don’t know who this is by…!)

Really though, i feel i’m the only one who didn’t put on anything classical. (Well not the ONLY one.)

Too hard to limit it to three. But this is the best I could do.

That’s Ok, you included Dark Side of the Moon, so you’re redeemed

Would anyone have thrown potato skins at me if I had included the Monkees’ Greatest Hits? :smiley:

As long as i didn’t have to listen to it, no, I wouldn’t feed you to the sharks!:smiley:

Hey its pretty good! Very good in fact. Am I the only one who believes as such?

And supposing I had brought it along, and played it really loudly supposing your island was floating a few feet from mine and you were loudly blasted w/ the sounds of “Daydream Believer”- would you fire monkey asses and bull testicles at me? (I’m kind of hoping you’ll say yes.)

Maybe monkey asses. But not bull testicals. That’s just silly.

Led Zeppelin: Led Zeppelin I
Black Sabbath: Sabbath Bloody Sabbath
Tangerine Dream: Pergamon

[li]Jazz Sebastien Bach - the Swingle Singers (since the limit is 3 CDs, I thought I’d combine Bach with jazz.)[/li]
Ravel: The Complete Piano Music, played by Robert Casadesus (2 CDs).

The Smiths: Louder Than Bombs (I only choose that one because it has the most songs per single CD as compared to the rest of their albums)

The Cure: Disintegration

The Beatles: Abbey Road

Honorable Mentions- (if one of the above is not available)
The Pixies: Doolittle

The Stone Roses: Second Coming

Creedence Clearwater Revival: Best Of…

Natural Born Killers: The Soundtrack

Pearl Jam- Yield
Nirvana- In Utero
Chevelle- Point #1

I would bring 3 blank CDs and a laptop computer (with the internet, of course) so that I can download stuff from Napster! Yeah, yeah I know that this would be cheating. But you did say that this was a rhetorical …um, er… hypothetical question, didn’t you?

My runner up CD’s would be:

Pulp Fiction Soundtrack
Best of Janis Joplin
Possibly, Appetite for Destruction

Though I admit, it would get boring listening to the same 3 over and over. Couldn’t we just rotate?

Well, 3 is certainly easier than 1 (but not by much):

  • Velvet Underground - Disc 2 of Peel Slowly and See Box (contains first LP + a few nice extras)
  • The Stooges - Funhouse
  • Gram Parsons - GP/Return of the Grievous Angel

HenrySpencer

Hokay,
[ul][li]Bizet, L’Arlesienne Suites 1 & 2; Carmen Suites 1 & 2, Dutoit, Orchestre symphonie de Montreal.[/li][li]Miles Davis, Kind of Blue.[/li][li]Cream, The Very Best of Cream.[/li][/ul]