I’ll give it a 6, because I like the beat and it’s easy to dance to.
A Passion Play wasn’t a shabby bit of work either, as Ian Anderson magnum opuses go. (And it was damned hard not to fall for the ballerina on the back cover . . . )
Of course, Keith Jarrett’s The Celestial Hawk doesn’t really count in this catagory, but it’ll bring a tear to the eye of even a hard core rock fan . . .
I’ll weigh in with the first Rush song, although I’m sure Coldy will be along shortly. “2112” - great song, and I am SO pissed I missed a chance to see it live on their last tour. Often turned it up full blast after a shitty day in college – might just go do that now.
Ah, but not all the all-day wonders are from the prog-rock crowd
I am quite fond of The Who’s “Won’t Get Fooled Again” – eight minutes plus, or about 45 minutes when they played it live – and Deep Purple’s “Lazy,” which runs about seven and a half minutes.
“Inna Gadda Da Vida” by Iron Butterfly…just because on a Simpson’s episode they sang it in church as a hymn (In the garden of eden…baby) The organist did a twenty minute solo and fainted after it…(she was old)…makes me laugh just to think about it.
–Gail
“Predictable, really I suppose. It was an act of purest optimism to have posed the question in the first place.” --John Cleese
I’ll second Falcon’s “2112” suggestion. Also, I’d like to add a few:
Rush - Hemispheres (Cygnus X1, part II);
Rush - Cygnus X1 (This song is the DEFINITION of “playing as if your life depended on it”);
Yes - Soundchaser (this will get you high without any outside help - it is as amazing as it is absurd);
Marillion - Brave (actually, it’s a concept album with many great pieces, but I can’t really pick one - just buy the damn thing!);
Twelfth Night - The Collector (This is possibly my all-time favourite long track. Does anybody even KNOW this?? It is brilliant, every prog rock fan should check it out!);
Fates Warning - Monument;
Dream Theater - Metropolis, pt. I;
Pink Floyd - Shine on you crazy Diamond;
Pink Floyd - High Hopes (proof that it is possible to write a brilliant PF song without the help of Waters);
Dire Straits - Telegraph Road.
Oh MAN, I could go on for hours. DAMN, I have great taste in music
Coldfire Voted Poster Most Likely To Post Drunk
WallyM7 on Coldfire: "Yeah, he knows a little about everything because they have a good prison library."
Add votes for Thick as a Brick and Shine on You Crazy Diamond, which were my first two thoughts.
Kinda too bad that modern drug habits won’t let the musicians go 20 minutes without heart failure or something… none of the groups I listen to go much past 5 any more.
http://www.madpoet.com
“I never meant to hurt you,” you said,
And buried yourself in lies instead.
Next time I would rather be slain,
Than forced to bear your mercy again.
ColdFire: Marillion, Fates Warning, and Dream Theatre! Man, that brings back memories!
I remember I used to be surprised that Iron Butterfly would do hour-long versions of Inna-Godda-Da-Vida live. But then I thought: it’s Iron Butterfly. What else do they have to do on stage? Their other hit?
How about Carnage Visors by the Cure? Or Tubular Bells? Does that count?