Hmmmm, distinct sens of urban legend here, well not necassarily urban in that its ‘recorded’ by ‘writers’.
Biggest load of tosh I ever read.
Having served in the Royal Navy, I can vouch that the incidence on homosexuality in the lower decks was vanishingly small, never ever once saw or even heard of a case where anyone was disciplined for this.
We certainly had security training films and presentations that put the case that homosexuality could leave a serving Navy rating vulnerable to blackmail and from there this could lead to becoming a risk to security - mainly in the radio and communications sections, but also in other departments.
Aside from this, the reality is that homosexuality during my time was seen with pretty extreme disdain - its not any sort of stretch to say that there was a good deal of homphobia - not that this is something to be proud about - but given that the average age of crew is less than 25, and actually the majority of the crew are rather less than that age, you can see how homphobia and peer pressure would make it very difficult to be either a closeted homosexual, and impossible to be an openly gay person.
I am not denying that there were gay men in the Royal Navy - its just that it was so incredibly rare, I served a goodly few years, never met any and in the rumour mill of the Royal Navy, never ever heard of any gay cases, not any.
Rumour carries far and long in the Royal Navy - I heard little ditties that had to have happened over 30 years before I signed up so the chances of missiing a few choice scandals such as these are remote and would certainly have made the rounds.
I think that this is all wishful thinking.
It seems to me that there is a fascination with homosexuality in closed male environments, I work in a prison and there seems to be a belief that male rape and homosexuality are very common, when in fact these are very rare.
When you have a large number of young males together, the peer pressure to conform is huge, you cannot underestimate it, and anyone outside the norm had better have two good fists, or keep damned quiet about it.
Sorry to burst somebodys gay dream, but homosexuality in such institutions is hugely overexagerrated - probably says more about the dreamers than such organisations.