Same Name, Different Character

The other day my mind wandered to a memory of a scene from Hill Street Blues which featured officer Bobby Hill. This of course made me think of young Bobby Hill of King of the Hill. Two characters with the same name, couldn’t be more different.

That in turn reminded me of the period when Friends and ER were on the same channel on the same night. Sometimes you could see Rachel Green and then Rachel Greene (Dr. Mark Greene’s daughter) within an hour of each other. (These two, I think, had more in common than the two Bobby Hills.)

What other homonymous pairs are out there in the world of fictional characters?

Eric Foreman on That 70s Show, and Dr. Eric Foreman on House. Completely different in personalities and looks.

IMO the most famous example is Homer Simpson from the Simpsons and Homer Simpson from The Day of the Locust.

And this occasionally throws me. How could they surplant the original Eric? Dang cottages!

Which made it interesting when the actor that played Red (Eric Foreman’s dad) on That 70’s Show played a patient’s dad on House.

Charlie Brown, Charlie Brown, he’s a clown, that Charlie Brown.

Which is not the one in Peanuts.

The Doctor in ST: Voyager and the Doctor.

In Lost Girls Alan Moore has Wendy Darling (from Peter Pan) married to Harold Potter. His character in a risque fantasy comic is very different from Rowling’s Harry Potter fantasy character, and predates him by several years (having first appeared in 1991)

Not to mention Homer Simpson from Police Cops.

Who is a sharp contrast to Homer Simpson from Polce Cops, who in turn is actually a lot like Homer Simpson.

IIRC, Homer Simpson of the cartoon show was partially named after the “Day of the Locust” character. Matt Groening gave his Simpsons the first names of his family members (his father was named Homer), and while casting about for a surname for his fictitious family thought of Homer Simpson from “The Day of the Locusts.”

On an episode of Big Valley, the madame in a brothel was named “Any Carter.” Watching it in reruns during Jimmy’s Presidency gave us the giggles.

There’s a Yanto Jones in Mine, All Mine and a Ianto Jonesin Torchwood, but they’re both Gareth David-Lloyd in unrelated Russell T Davies programs.

I recently caught part of a 90s TV movie, …And Then She Was Gone, starring Robert Urich as Jack Bauer. Not that Jack Bauer; some other Jack Bauer.

Not exactly the same thing, but did you ever see the U.S. version of the original Godzilla? Raymond Burr is intercut into the original (albeit dubbed) Japanese footage to provide a hook for English audiences. Name: Steve Martin.

–Cliffy

Two Harry Potters in Troll.

Leela from Doctor Who

Leela from Futurama

I still say he should have played Foreman’s dad on House.

Bert and Ernie from It’s a Wonderful Life and Bert and Ernie from Sesame Street

In To Have and Have Not, Bogart played “Harry Morgan,” not to be confused with the pirate or the actor. There also seems to be a “Harry Morgan” on Dexter. No wonder Bacall called him “Steve.”

Rick Hunter from *Robotech *and Rick Hunter from Hunter. [/80s_kid]