You’re a Yankees fan? Did I know that already? Let the record show that this post is the last where I will ever address you directly. 
I don’t know how ‘SDMB Keeper’ works their system. I’ll ask Zev later.
Speaking of Zev, and since you brought it up, you’re going to be one of the expansion teams in the OOTP league after this season, aren’t you?
Anyway, I don’t like that system you outlined because it rewards you for making bad decisions and failing to plan ahead. And it sort of ruins the whole concept of having a keeper league, doesn’t it? If you like my 4th best player better than some of yours, just choose not to keep your guys and you get to draft from mine instead? Nah. That pays off teams with bad players because you can just vulture everyone else’s surplus instead of keeping your own.
I understand it’s not as extreme as I make it out to be, I guess. You’re giving up your potential #1 to pick over everyone else’s #4s. Okay, now I’m thinking about it. But it just doesn’t sit right with me to let somebody have first crack at the draft pool as a result of their not having had enough good players to keep. I dunno.
You’re right about Jeter to some extent (I didn’t realize he had missed that many games), but I still don’t see him as a standout keeper candidate.
Just for giggles I compared him to my favorite player (Trot Nixon of course), who had 441 ABs this year to the Jete’s 472. He scored 4 fewer runs (batting almost exclusively from the 6, 7, and 8 spots in the order), 16 fewer hits (the difference between .306 and .320), equal doubles, almost three times as many homers (28 to 10), 87 RBI to 52, and even threw in 4 SBs to Jeter’s 10. His OBP was marginally higher and of course his slugging was where he really shone, combining for a heroic OPS of .975 to Jeter’s humdrum .837.
So Jeter offers slightly better BA (BA ONLY, not OBP or OPS) and a few more steals than a guy that won’t be drafted before the 6th round at the earliest.
Okay, so positionally Jeter has a huge advantage over any outfielder. Why don’t we have a look at Trot’s teammate Todd Walker. He’s got 576 ABs this year so we can multiply all his counting stats by 82% to come a little closer to Jeter’s numbers.
Runs: Jeter 85 Walker 90 (equiv to 74)
2B: Jeter 24 Walker 37 (eq. 30)
HR Jeter 10 Walker 12 (eq 10)
RBI Jeter 52 Walker 83 (eq 68)
Walker doesn’t steal bases, and Jeter hits better than he does (.283/.333 to .320/.390)
So Jeter has runs, steals, and BA/OBP, Walker has 2B and RBI, HRs are even. Jeter’s probably a better producer. But there isn’t even a mention of Walker as a keeper, and I don’t think I’d be hard-pressed to win the argument that there’s more strength in the AL at SS than at 2B. Anybody wanna see me do this comparison for Jeter and Mueller? Jeter doesn’t even come close anywhere but runs (comparable) and steals (Mueller doesn’t run either). I think I’d argue that AL SS is also stronger than AL 3B as a position. Of course, Mueller’s just experienced something that goes beyond the concept of a ‘career year,’ but then so did Ortiz and Fewl is recommending him for potential keeper status.
Yeah, I’d keep Colon over Santana. He’s a proven commodity and is virtually guaranteed to pitch his 200 innings at the top of any rotation in any given season. Santana’s raw and untested and struggled at times this year (due partially of course to the way Gardenhire used him). He’s no ace, not yet anyway. Are you telling me you’d draft Santana, right now, for next season before you’d draft Colon?