I’ll take Book Smarts, Athleticism, Good Looks, and Charisma. I’ve managed to survive without common sense in real life.
- Book Smarts 9
- Common Sense 13
- Good Looks 11
- Athleticism 15
- Charisma 13
By the way, when I specified 1 Charisma, this is what I meant. (Mildly NSFW) 
Hmmm, lets see. I will take one of each Book Smarts and Athleticism. I will finish with 2x Charisma because who needs Good Looks when women will find themselves inexplicably drawn to me anyway.
- Book Smarts (8)
- Common Sense (13)
- Good Looks (11)
- Athleticism (14)
- Charisma (11)
Hmm. Looks like we’re running out of Book Smarts. I’ll decide overnight wether to restock or replace. We’ll see. I’m not going to bother re-counting, because I’ve been following the thread and it looks like you’re all doing a good job tallying up.
Oh heck, give me 2 athleticisms, since I’ve never had any before. I’d like to run a 10 miles marathon one day.
Then one charisma and one common sense.
- Book Smarts (8)
- Common Sense (12)
- Good Looks (11)
- Athleticism (12)
- Charisma (10)
So long as I’m moderately healthy, I don’t mind if I’m not athletic. I haven’t been my entire life and it’s not hurt me too much so far.
- Book Smarts (7)
- Common Sense (11)
- Good Looks (10)
- Athleticism (12)
- Charisma (9)
Charisma, Charisma, Good Looks, and Common sense
- Book Smarts (7)
- Common Sense (10)
- Good Looks (9)
- Athleticism (12)
- Charisma (7)
Definitely deficient in Common Sense so I’ll take a double helping of that plus Good Looks and Charisma, leaving…
- Book Smarts (7)
- Common Sense (8)
- Good Looks (8)
- Athleticism (12)
- Charisma (6)
Dopers pick anything other than Athleticism. There’s a surprise! 
I will take all but good looks. A friend of mine is not a good looking guy but gals can’t get enough of him, so looks aren’t everything.
- Book Smarts (6)
- Common Sense (7)
- Good Looks (8)
- Athleticism (11)
- Charisma (5)
I’ll take one of the athleticism, two of the charisma, and one of the common sense.
That’s:
- Book Smarts (6)
- Common Sense (6)
- Good Looks (8)
- Athleticism (10)
- Charisma (3)
I’ll take a Book Smarts, a Common Sense, an Athleticism and a Charisma, please.
- Book Smarts (5)
- Common Sense (5)
- Good Looks (8)
- Athleticism (9)
- Charisma (2)
I propose we nickname the last poster to this thread “Sporty Spice” for at least a day.
For me, skip the Good Looks and Athleticism - take a double of Common Sense - leaves
- Book Smarts (4)
- Common Sense (3)
- Good Looks (8)
- Athleticism (9)
- Charisma (1)
(With Charisma, the ones skipped probably aren’t so important.)
– If you’re going to re-stock, could you put in an order for Humor? Much obliged.
- Book Smarts 1
- Common Sense 2
- Good Looks
- Athleticism
- Charisma 1
That leaves…
- Book Smarts (3)
- Common Sense (1)
- Good Looks (8)
- Athleticism (9)
- Charisma 0
Shotgun the last unpicked choice.
I’d rather have Good looks and common sense than what I have now.
Book smarts are nice and all, but it doesn’t keep you from losing your damn car every time you park.
Quote o’the day, said to me:
I will trade you half of my common sense for a quarter of your test taking ability. I’d love to pass tests and I’m sure you’d enjoy being able to walk ten feet without hurting yourself.
Well. We’re out of charisma, and almost out of common sense and book smarts. Folks’ll have to make due with what’s left while I decide what to do about this.
Daon’t forget: the world needs ditch diggers, too.
All right. Since we’re all out of charisma, I’ll replenish stock. And a couple things to remember: athleticism will get you laid just as much as good looks (more or less), and charisma X3 + good looks X1 could win you the presidency of the US of A.
- Book Smarts (3)
- Common Sense (1)
- Good Looks (8)
- Athleticism (9)
- Charisma (25)