Watching John Wayne in “Rio Grande” the other night,it occured to me that in all the old cavalry movies,the corporal’s and sergeant’s stripes are point-downward.They still are in England,Canada,et.al.,but here in the States, they’re now point-upward.When and why were they switched? All I could come up with was: A)anti-Brit sentiment,or more likely,B)the Army didn’t want their chevron’s looking like the Navy’s.Anyone got the Straight Dope?
I think if you look again, you’ll see that that the Duke’s sergeant’s stripes (or, more likely, Victor McLaughlin’s) point upward and downward.
Usually, the first two or three stripes are point upward. But additional stripes (called “arcs”) were added to differentiate between the various sergeants.
Here’s the current insignia:
Corporal – two chevrons
Sergeant – three chevrons
Staff Sergeant – three chevrons above one arc.
Sergeant 1st Class – 3 chevrons, two arcs
Master Sergeant – 3 chevrons, three arcs
First Sergeant – 3 chevrons, 3 arcs, with a lozenge between them
Etc.
That’s how they appeared in SHE WORE A YELLOW RIBBON and FORT APACHE, just to name a couple of John Wayne westerns. Wayne wasn’t a mere sergeant in these, but others were.
“What we have here is failure to communicate.” – Strother Martin, anticipating the Internet.
According to this site from the U.S. Navy Historical Center, chevrons (the V shaped stripes) were used from the late 1700s to 1851 (for the U.S. Army) in a number of different ways to indicate levels of rank up to captain and for to show length of service.
In 1851, the U.S. Army changed to a consistent system of chevrons indicating rank of NCO’s with the points down. In 1902, the Army reversed the chevrons, putting them point up and began using the pattern we see today.
The Marine Corps, on the other hand, adopted a system like the current one in 1959.
You don’t have a thing to worry about. I’ll have the jury eating out of my hand. Meanwhile, try to escape.
Sig by Wally M7, master signature architect to the SDMB
Air Force chevrons point down.
“I must leave this planet, if only for an hour.” – Antoine de St. Exupéry
Are you a turtle?
Realitychuck…
Not real sure why you call an upside down “rainbow” an arc…but all the rest of us Army dudes called them rockers.
Sex is like bridge: If you don’t have a good partner, you better have a good hand.
– Charles Pierce
Just to throw in my unique ability to remember every line from everymovie I have ever seen:
Officer: (indicating stripes on arm)“What does three up and three down mean to you, soldier?!?”
Private Cronauer: “End of an inning?”
Anyone know the reference?
A related question: In the Fail Safe remake, one of the characters (I think at NORAD) had something like 5 or 6 chevrons and 8 or 9 arcs. Is/was this a real rank? Or a Hollywood muff that was supposed to make him look like an important enlisted officer?
Do they literally rip the stripes off you when you’re demoted? If so, I guess velcro helps, huh?
“They’re coming to take me away ha-ha, ho-ho, hee-hee, to the funny farm where life is beautiful all the time… :)” - Napoleon IV
Thanks for the comments,but I’m still a little confused.I know about rockers on Army/Navy/Marine/CG chevrons,but I was only talking about the first 3 stripes,going up to “buck” Sgt.rank.Why were they switched to point-up?
Air Force chevrons don’t actually point,they curve.(E-7 to E-9 use Army-type chevrons on top).The movie reference is “Good
Morning,Vietnam”,but it was Airman Cronauer,not Private.
:eek: Oops!
Thanks for the correction, Brian!
:::sheepishly backs away:::
To:mrblue92:If you’re thinking about the rather chunky Sgt who was ordered to tell the Russians information when the colonel refused to,yes,he was an Air Force Chief Master Sergeant(CMSgt),the top enlisted rank.I had to give them Brownie points for attention to detail here,since he was wearing the correct "old"insignia of 6 curved chevrons down,2 pointed ones on top,appropriate for the 60’s,when the show was set.A couple years ago,they changed it to 5 down,3 on top.The khaki uniform he was wearing was called the “1505”,and was (sadly)phased out in 1978. OK,I’m still waiting an answer to my original question!
More than you ever wanted to know on this subject, courtesy of the United State’s Army’s Institute of Heraldry (my apologies if this extends the window):
http://www-perscom.army.mil/tagd/tioh/rank/enlisted.htm
FWIW, I recall seeing the US Army Band playing in Dress Blues and some of the NCOs were wearing their chevrons with the points down. This was back in 1984.
A couple of additional points:
1: A chevron is a heraldric device which goes all the way back to Old French. Originally, a chevron was a roof rafter, hence the name was applied to the “/”, or inverted V, found in European family crests and battle flags.
2: sdimbert – 'Twasn’t an “officer” who queried Airman Cronauer as to three up and three down. It was the first sergeant (or master sergeant, I didn’t catch whether there was a diamond on his insignia).
Homepage: http://www.bigfuckinboatwithbadassplanes.mil
Occupation: Swabbie Pounder, First Class
Location: Anywhere you feckless landlubbers ain’t.
Interests: Navy Chow, Port of Call, The Head, Air Superiority
ICQ Number: CVN69 – An UncleBeer Profile
“Avast and ahoy, landlubbers! Shore leave’s in August. Hide your women.” – A WallySig
Chief: Actually, 'twas an officer, a senior noncommissioned one to be exact.
The following categories of officer exist in the United States Military:
- Commissioned
- Warrant
- Petty
& - Non-commissioned.
At least so says the UCMJ.
Yeah, yeah, Monty.
But I’m sure if you called a master sergeant an officer he (or she) would take umbrage.
I know I would.
Homepage: http://www.bigfuckinboatwithbadassplanes.mil
Occupation: Swabbie Pounder, First Class
Location: Anywhere you feckless landlubbers ain’t.
Interests: Navy Chow, Port of Call, The Head, Air Superiority
ICQ Number: CVN69 – An UncleBeer Profile
“Avast and ahoy, landlubbers! Shore leave’s in August. Hide your women.” – A WallySig
Chief, just because someone doesn’t like something doesn’t mean it’s not true. Or are you not familiar with the full title of noncommissioned officer or chief petty officer or even chief warrant officer?
Let me break it down:
Noncommissioned (adjective)
Officer (noun)
&
Chief (adjective)
Petty (adjective)
Officer (noun)
How about this?
Chief (adjective)
Warrant (adjective)
Officer (noun)
So, anyway, if only commissioned officers are officers (which I think I proved is not the case), why are two classes of officers saluted?
Monty-Thanks for the website.Yeah,the subject does get pretty involved,doesn’t it? It still didn’t say WHY they switched,so I guess the Army itself doesn’t know,which sounds about right!I guess I’ll stick to my theory that they didn’t want to look like the squids.