It’s pretty simple: if likes affect sorting, e.g. the most “upvoted” posts go to the top, that’s where all the incentive comes from. Once you remove sorting, if likes are merely a part of the normal ambient data displayed on any post, like the date, time, username, view count (for topics) and all that… there is way less risk of people behaving in odd ways to get likes.
There’s a good overview of “why likes?” on the official Discourse forum:
Avoiding repetition
Likes help you keep your forum clean. On forums without a “Like” button, when someone posts something that other users agree with, you end up seeing a lot of very short, redundant replies. For example:
Game Company OP: Every player gets 100 free loot boxes for Christmas!
Reply 1: Awesome!
Reply 2: Heck yeah
Reply 3: So cool
Reply 4: Thanks
…
Reply 100000: OMG this is amazingSince forums typically have a lot of vertical space for each post, this means that a casual reader has to scroll past dozens or hundreds of such posts!
I’d also add that it simply feels good to express “wow that was a cool post, thanks!” in a straightforward way that doesn’t clutter the discussion.
I do miss the like button here for that reason. So many great posts by really interesting people – and a few total dipsticks, per the official byline. ![]()
It’s probably OK for a forum with a decade long history of not having a like button, to take some time deciding if they want to add it. No rush. Hopefully this place will still be around and chugging 10-20 years from now… one of my personal doomsday scenarios is “everything becomes a Facebook company town” and that’s, to be totally honest with you, why I wake up every day and work on this open source project ![]()
![]()