For those who may be interested in widening their knowledge, I humbly offer the following small history lesson;
Most of the subjugated nations of SE Asia achieved independence following the second world war. The colonial powers would have us believe their consciousness had been raised, times and attitudes had changed. But that is an exceedingly generous view, in my opinion.
The first time the British fleet was ever defeated was off the coast of Malaysia, as the Japanese began their march across peninsular Malaysia the British retreated to Kuala Lumpur and Penang. As the Japanese grew nearer they, with their wives and children, jumped on the last train to Singapore. Leaving the Malays to fend for themselves.
Once in S’pore it became clear the Japanese were still advancing on them. So they prepared to do the same, getting the last boat to Australia with their families. Only this time they did not want to leave any resources that could be of any use to their enemy. So they went about destroying every factory, etc, and the only source of fresh water. Having destroyed the island they jumped on the boat and high tailed it out of town.
The war ended shortly thereafter but not before thousands of S’poreans died not just at the hands of the Japanese but because there was no water, hospitals or resources left to support them. An entire generation of S’poreans grew up not knowing their grand parents, all dead in the war. A very big deal in an Asian culture.
An eye opener for all the subjugated peoples of Asia who would never allow themselves to be colonized again, and rightly so. From the ashes of what was left of S’pore there rose a young man, who claimed he had a vision that could lead his people into prosperity and peace.
That man was Lee Kwon Yue (sorry about the spelling). Not without his faults he did what he promised. Within 30 yrs S’pore was the tiger economy of SE Asia, it’s people enjoying a standard of living still the envy of most of Asia. They enjoy education, full employment, access to world class health care, the worlds third largest port and prosperity, to this day, largely because of that man’s vision. This is a small island nation with few natural resources that runs now, and largely always has, at a surplus.
Did he suppress opposition during this time? He did, not with troops or death squads, but he had big visions and knew it would slow him down, right or wrong. Will their be a cost to the nation without a history of balanced opposition to government, very likely. But these are their choices to live with.
They just kept on electing him because he kept improving, substantially, their lives. Asian culture is very different from the west, it works more on a father child relationship rather than one of equals that we hold in such esteem. When he said, ‘I want you to speak more Mandarin’, they did it. If he said, ‘Eat more brown rice’, they did. They continue to have politeness campaigns and the like to this day. And the west, largely misunderstands it all.
Often the west is want to foist democracy upon nations ill prepared to make it work. Moreover they love to stand in judgment of the democracy of other nations in whatever detail it varies from their own.
Asian culture is very different from ours, spraypainting an automobile may be considered a childhood prank on our side of the pond. But in their culture nothing is considered as vile as waste. And to destroy a piece of personal property worth thousands of dollars, just for giggles, is viewed very, very differently.
As to criticism of the government, again, the Asian view is more father child. Do not criticize the father, it shows the worst manners and is a terrible sin. Whereas here in the west we often elect leaders and then spend their entire term tearing them apart, and placing obstacles in their way to keep them from actualizing their goals. Witness Republican President, Democratic congress. In Canada, we have minority and coalition governments who can achieve little, more often than not these days. So tell me who is better off for these ‘freedoms’? We have leaders we don’t respect, hell, many of us think they are morons. Is that really a better system?
Truth is there is no perfect form of government. But it’s time for the west to understand their way is not the ONLY way. If the citizenry of other nations are happy with their form of democracy or other government then I say we shut up and stay the hell out of it. Bob Dylan said it best, “Don’t criticize what you don’t understand,” !