I was carefulling watching that thread. There were a few ongoing discussions I was watching in it.
Not since people have posted a few pics of their cats, you closed it?
It had over 600 posts. People liked it. I cannot see what was harmed in leaving it be. Isn’t it the responsibility of the MODS to correct people if they stray off topic? Shouldn’t you be encouraging them to start another thread?
Maybe the thread itself had strayed a bit, but why close it?
If a thread is new and hasn’t already reached, say, thirteen pages, I think rescuing it from a hijack can be a noble thing indeed. If, on the other hand, it’s a picture thread that’s lasted for as long as the closed thread in question–with the last handful of posts dedicated to pet photos–then a closing is kinda like a mercy killing. (Only, less blood.) Hijacks at the end of multi-page threads like that one usually indicate that the discussion has run out of steam. There’s no sense in prolonging its life; might as well make room on the front page for newer threads.
Besides, a new picture thread tends to pop up every few weeks or so (or even every few months). If you wait long enough, someone will start a new thread and people will be rushing to it to tell the world how nice I look.
I don’t see how that’s possible. Every time I look at a photo of you I can’t really discern any features because of the great shining reflection off of your ethereal pallor…