A friend of mine (who had kids before we did) told me that I might as well just start with admitting to the ‘mean mommy’ thing from the first trial of toddlerhood. When I do something I know my son doesn’t like (a lot), I calmly admit to being the meanest mommy in the world. It makes me feel better if I say it first. And eventually, they realize that it isn’t true, even if they wish they could make the term stick. There’s so much that is meaner than what you did! (or what I do…)
(the following happened after I made the mistake of actually buying a package of gummy bears at the grocery store…)
Gabe: I want gummy bears! (says the 3-yr-old at 6:30 in the morning)
Mean Mommy: Nope, sorry. No gummy bears for breakfast. You can have muffins, or cereal.
G: I WANT GUMMY BEARS FOR BREFFAST!
MM: First, no gummy bears for breakfast. Second, you didn’t say please. Third, even if you say please, gummy bears are still not for breakfast. And fourth, you didn’t use a nice voice. You can have some after lunch if you eat a good lunch, but you cannot have any for breakfast.
G: (extra cute routine) But I wike gummy bears for breakfast. PWEESE!??? (blink blink, smile sweetly)
MM: Thanks for asking so nicely, but sorry, too bad, gummy bears are still not for breakfast. Cereal, muffins - or, hey, yogurt, if you want?
G: (crying and angry faces, stubbornly saying nothing)
MM: (half to myself) Yep, I’m the meanest mommy in the world, not letting you have gummy bears for breakfast. Cereal, muffins, or yogurt?
G: I don’t WANT you to be a mean mommy! (stomp) I don’t WIKE mean mommies. (scowl)
MM: (sadly, but understandingly) Oh, that’s too bad. Cereal, muffins, or yogurt?
G: (starting to realize he’s going to lose) Don’t say that. That’s BAD. Don’t say ‘too bad’ I don’t wike it! (desperately) I want gummy bears!
MM: Cereal, muffins, or yogurt.
G: (pause… sniffle) … (subdued) Cereal, pwease. (perking up) Mommy cereal - fwosted fwakes!
I also make him brush his teeth, at least TRY to limit the number of time-wasters before bed, and enforce other horrible rules like holding hands when crossing the street. Meanie.
And my mom made me go to school when I was sick with terror because of not having done my homework (second grade; I’d told her I didn’t have any, because I wanted to play). I wish she had explained it half so well as you did (I didn’t need it to get the grades, I needed it to learn how to follow through and be responsible for assigned tasks even if I didn’t like them). I wish she had kept browbeating me about it, too - I simply declined to do most homework from second grade on through high school. (afterall, I could wing it and still get decent grades…) It took me getting a set of mid-term D’s in college to get with the program. Even scarier, then. And harder to learn. I’m still working on that one.
I don’t think you’ve won Mean Mommy of the Year, yet. Keep trying, you might get a shot at one of the 10 runner-up slots, though! (My friend from the first paragraph says she has won it a few years running, according to her kids…)