It occured to me I have have been misinterpreting a song all my life.
Does the Chorus mean Reeling(“The fisherman is slowly reeling the largemouth Bass back to shore”) or Reeling(“The Boxer is really reeling after that huge uppercut”)?
Is the song talking about someone trying to pull the years back in, or trying to keep his balance as he is battered by the passing of them?
“Reeling in” is a fishing term, there’s no other way to read it. If it was reeling from the years, the boxing thing would work. The fact that the next line also has a nautical theme - “stowing away the time” - also shows it’s a fishing thing.
Otherwise you have to read the lyric as meaning ‘reeling from the years,’ which doesn’t make sense.