Have you got a song that was good
So good that as you get really into it
It ends, and you go like Janet Jackson
at the end of “Escapade”?
That you have to play it twice
In a row to get a semblance
Of length, if not resolution
It may include songs that are missing verses from the original
Here are two of mine:
“Charlie Brown” by the Coasters
“She’s Leaving Home” by the Beatles
“Don’t Mug Yourself” by The Streets
The shortest song ever to reach number one in Billboard’s ratings? “Stay”, by Maurice Williams and the Zodiacs clocked in at one minute, fifty-eight seconds. It’s good to play it twice.
Welcome to the Working Week by Elvis Costello is just too short. Such a great song, but it only lasts a couple of minutes or so. And I can’t put it on repeat cause it’s this weird black plastic thing that my Dad’s got.
so far, that’s the best vote: it does seem not only short, but incomplete: most other songs are either short for humorous effect (“old mother reagan” violent femmes) or short because they’ve said all they needed to (“lets go pop” by the figgs), but it didnt seem he was done here.
another candidate: “Warm fuzzy feeling” by fastball.
Girlfriend by Matthew Sweet. It really harkens back to some pure rock sound and I love the way he busts out with a damn good guitar solo. Too short though.
Whenever I hear “Burning Down the House” by Talking Heads, I always think it ends too soon. Luckily, there’s the live version where they just jam forever.