Skeleton Key.
I haven’t read all the suggestions, but you might enjoy Grandaddy. Sophtware Slump is a great album.
The Donkey Headed Adversary of Humanity makes a good suggestion!
As much as I like this band, it was more fey than dark…
Indeed. I love that song.
I recommend checking out Slim Cessna’s Auto Club, and if you get a chance to see them live, don’t miss it.
They’re long over, but Thin White Rope did some of the most amazing dark psychedelia ever put to vinyl. Here they are kicking the crap out of a Nancy Sinatra / Lee Hazelwood song.