Strange Dewey Decimal order

I was looking in the European Travel section of my local library yesterday. This is the order in which the books were arranged:

Scotland
Ireland
England
Wales
Germany
Austria
Czech Republic
Poland
Hungary
France
Italy
Spain
Portugal
Latvia
Russia
Georgia
Ukrania
Estonia
Lithuania
Norway
Sweden
Denmark
Finland
Iceland
Holland
Belgium
Switzerland
Greece
Istanbul (Turkey)
Croatia
Slovenia
Bulgaria

I would have expected them to be in some sort of geographical order, or even alphabetical. It occurred to me that the order might reflect Dewey’s 19th-century bias, putting the British Isles first, followed by Germany and Austria, etc. But this doesn’t make sense either; Why should Poland trump France? Why should Iceland come before Holland, Belgium, Switzerland and Greece?

Can anyone explain the logic (if any) of this order?

A lot of it really is because the map of Europe was drawn entirely differently in 1894, when Dewey first established his divisions. The major powers were the UK, Germany, the Austro-Hungarian Empire, France, Italy, Spain , and Russia. If you look at it that way the connections make more sense.

I checked my 8th edition (abridged) of the Dewey Decimal Classification, from 1959. It doesn’t break out the travel section for Europe, 914, but it does go into detail for European history, which is the 940s. Here’s how it breaks down:

941 Scotland
941.5 Ireland

942 England
942.9 Wales

943 Germany
943.1 Prussia (East Germany was put here later)
943.6 Austria (includes Lichtenstein, which used to be part of the empire)
943.7 Czechoslovakia
943.8 Poland
943.9 Hungary, Transylvania, Slavonia, Croatia, Bosnia, and Herzegovina (why Hungary is included with the Balkan states when it was nominally co-equal with Austria I can’t understand)

944 France

945 Italy

946 Spain
946.9 Portugal

947 Russia
947.1 Finland (didn’t become independent until 1917, after the Russian revolution)

948 Scandinavia
948.1 Norway
948.5 Sweden
948.9 Denmark

949 Other areas of Europe
949.1 Iceland
949.2 Netherlands
949.3 Belgium
949.35 Luxembourg
949.4 Switzerland
949.5 Greece
949.6 Balkan States (didn’t we already do this? Nope. Includes “Balkan Peninsula, Danube River, Turkey in Europe, Ottoman Empire 1288-1918”)
949.65 Albania
949.7 Yugoslavia (created after WWII and subsumes some of the Balkans)
949.77 Bulgaria
949.8 Rumania
949.85 Soviet Moldavia
949.9 Islands of the Aegean Sea

This isn’t exactly equivalent to your list, but revisions keep being necessary as the map of Europe shifts.

And it’s clear that the perspective was purely Anglo-Saxon, dealing with the perceived importance of the nation and to a lesser extent the comparative number of books that would be placed in each division and subdivision.

Dewey was a prisoner of his time and perspective, even when it came to the U.S. How else to explain that the 19th century is covered by 973.4, 973.5, 973.6, 973.7 and 973.8, while the 20th century, which we now know to include many times as many books, is completely subsumed until 973.9 and no place whatsoever is provided for the 21th century and beyond?

Most of the order listed above was developed by the second edition of Dewey, in 1885 (only the broad outline was in the first edition, in 1876). However, there has been some movement since then, the most significant being that Finland has moved from being part of Russia to being part of Scandinavia (Finland was part of Russia from 1809 to 1917). Other changes reflect the break-up of the Austro-Hungarian empire, and changes with the former Soviet Union and the former Yugoslavia. So it reflects geography of the late 19th century. However, it has been updated to reflect modern goegraphy – but trying to avoid relocating material, because relocactions always cause proiblems for libraries.

The second point is that Dewey has a decimal notation, so that each topic gets divided up into 9 sections. In this case, you have 8 broad areas of Europe, followed by a miscellaneous section with everything not in the rest – which is a rather mixed bag, including the Low Countries, Switzerland, and southeastern Europe.

In detail (using the history numbers in 941 to 949 because that was where the details were first developed – the geigraohy numbers in 914.1 to 914.9 are parallel to them):

Scotland – 941 in edition 2, and 941.1 now, because 941 is now used for the UK as a whole
Ireland – 941.5 in edition 2: note there has been a litle readjustment, because part of Ireland is now independent
England – 942
Wales – 942.9
Germany – 943
Austria – 943.6
Czech Republic – 943.7 (It was Bohemia, etc., back in edition 2)
Poland – 943.8 (It was a lot smaller back in 1885 than it is now)
Hungary – 943.9
France – 944
Italy – 945
Spain – 946
Portugal – 946.9
Latvia – This isn’t the right place, since it was 947.4 in edition 2, as part of the “Baltic provinces” of Russia, and it’s now 947.96
Russia – 947
Georgia – 947.9 in edition 2, as part of “Caucasia”, and now 947.58
Ukrania – 947.7 (Called “Little Russia” in edition 2)
Estonia – 947.4 in edition 2, and 947.98 now
Lithuania – 947.4 in edition 2, and 947.93 now (so the order or Estonia and Lithuania doesn’t match Dewey here)
Norway – 948.1 (948 is Scandinavia)
Sweden – 948.5
Denmark – 948.9
Finland – 947.1 in edition 2, and 947.97 now (because there was a problem with all the other notation in 948 being used up for parts of Norway and Sweden)
Iceland – 949.1
Holland – 949.2
Belgium – 949.3
Switzerland – 949.4
Greece – 949.5 (but it was called “Byzantine Empire and Modern Greece” in edition 2)
Istanbul (Turkey) – 949.6 (the rest or Turkey is in Asia)
Croatia – in 943.6 in edition 2 (when it was part of Austria), and 949.72 now
Slovenia – in 943.6 in edition 2 (when it was part of Austria), and 949.73 now
Bulgaria – 949.7 in edition 2, and 949.9 now

But there’s another reason for some of the break up. Melvil Dewey tried to use the same notation to mean similar hings in different parts of the classification. If you look at the language break-up, you can see some parallels:

420 – English language
430 – German language
440 – French language
450 – Italian language
460 – Spanish language
469 – Portuguese language

That is obviously parallel with 942, 943, 944, 945, 946 and 946.9. (However, the parallel structure breaks down with 470 for Latin and 480 for Greek). This means that you can associate 5 meaning Italy in 945 with 5 meaning Italian in 450. However, there are costs. It means that the structure of the clkassification of languages is imperfect (apart from its bias towards languages found in late 19th-century American libraries), and the structure for European geography is imperfect – in an ideal structure, the Low Countries would be between Germany and France.

Just a small quibble: 973.93 is provided for the hiostory of the US in “the 21th century and beyond”. However, Exapno Mapcase is right in pointing out that Dewey gave promininence in the notation to late 19th century concerns, and later things have had to be fitted into an existing structure somewhere.

I’m sure it is now, but as late as 1959 there was no such mention. U.S. History stops with 973.921 Administration of Eisenhower, 1953-

I’ve used the Dewey system all my life (yes, I had a book in my hands while the doctor spanked me at birth) and I’m comfortable thinking in it. But it’s a terrible system in many ways. Retrofitting the future into the system’s extreme limitations is always awkward. And made much worse by the ridiculous inconsistency of the catalogers (there can be no justification for cataloging the paperback edition differently than the hardback edition!), but that’s a rant for another day.

BTW, I need to correct myself. 1894 is the date of the first edition of the Abridged edition, not the original full listing, as Giles properly points out.

The history numbers are also the basis for much of the geographic qualifiers for other subjects.

History’s of the United States economy are 330.973, of the UK 330.942.

Dewey has a very hard time dealing with books on computer science topics. Depending on the library, a lot of them get stuck in the 000s (General Knowledge), but other libraries have tried to place books about computers and programming and applications in areas depending upon what sort of person would be most interested in it.

So we put books on programming languages and operating systems in Science (in the math section), books on popular office applications (such as word processing and spreadsheets) in business books, desktop publishing in Literature, and things like Photoshop with art books.

Another big flaw of Dewey is that in the religion section, 90% of it is reserved for Christianity. Everything else gets jammed into 290-299. Because there aren’t many Jews, Buddhist, Moslems, Hindus, etc.