I don’t know about anyone else, but personally I will not ever be voting against The Tick, even if he is up against Bats. He is the greatest superhero in the history of superheroes.
SPOON!
Batman (26-1)
Shadowcat (Kitty Pride) (14-13)
The Tick (16-10-1)
Wonder Woman (22-5)
Wolverine (20-7)
Plastic Man (17-7-3)
pass
Swamp Thing (14-13)
Spider-Man (22-5)
pass
Storm (15-12)
Mister Fantastic (15-12)
pass
The Flash (Barry Allen) (20-7)
Nightwing/Robin (Dick Grayson) (18-9)
Hellboy (17-10)
Batman
The Flash
The Tick
Wonder Woman
[pass]
Plastic Man
Green Arrow (Oliver Queen)
Swamp Thing
Rorschach
Doctor Manhattan
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)
The Hulk
Superman
Captain Marvel (Billy Batson/DC/Shazam)
Silver Surfer
Hellboy
The Question vs Green Arrow. That’s funny. “Fascist!” “Commie!”
Batman (26-1)
Shadowcat (Kitty Pride) (14-13)
Nightcrawler (19-7-1)
Wonder Woman (22-5)
Wolverine (20-7)
Thor (23-4)
The Question (15-11-1)
Swamp Thing (14-13)
Rorschach (16-11)
Doctor Manhattan (18-6-3)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) (14-13)
Mister Fantastic (15-12)
Superman (24-3)
The Flash (Barry Allen) (20-7)
Silver Surfer (22-5)
Captain America (19-7-1)
[/QUOTE]
Saracen Pig! Spartan Dog! Turkish Taffy! 
Batman (26-1)
Shadowcat (Kitty Pride) (14-13)
Nightcrawler (19-7-1)
Hawkeye (16-11)
Rogue (15-12)
Thor (23-4)
Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) (16-11)
Martian Manhunter (Jonn J’onzz) (22-3-2)
Spider-Man (22-5)
Iron Man (19-8)
Storm (15-12)
The Hulk (18-8-1)
Superman (24-3)
The Flash (Barry Allen) (20-7)
Nightwing/Robin (Dick Grayson) (18-9)
Captain America (19-7-1)
[/QUOTE]
Batman (26-1)
The Flash (Wally West) (25-2)
The Tick (16-10-1)
Wonder Woman (22-5)
Rogue (15-12)
Plastic Man (17-7-3)
The Question (15-11-1)
Martian Manhunter (Jonn J’onzz) (22-3-2)
Spider-Man (22-5)
Iron Man (19-8)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) (14-13)
Mister Fantastic (15-12)
Superman (24-3)
Captain Marvel (Billy Batson/DC/Shazam) (16-10-1)
Nightwing/Robin (Dick Grayson) (18-9)
Captain America (19-7-1)
I don’t know enough about comic books to legitimately vote, but I will predict a winner.
Batman. No doubt in my mind.
Batman (26-1)
The Flash (Wally West) (25-2)
The Tick (16-10-1)
Wonder Woman (22-5)
Wolverine (20-7)
Plastic Man (17-7-3)
Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) (16-11)
Martian Manhunter (Jonn J’onzz) (22-3-2)
Rorschach (16-11)
Iron Man (19-8)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) (14-13)
Mister Fantastic (15-12)
Superman (24-3)
The Flash (Barry Allen) (20-7)
Silver Surfer (22-5)
Hellboy (17-10)
Batman (26-1)
The Flash (Wally West) (25-2)
The Tick (16-10-1)
Wonder Woman (22-5)
Plastic Man (17-7-3)
Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) (16-11)
Swamp Thing (14-13)
Spider-Man (22-5)
Iron Man (19-8)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) (14-13)
The Hulk (18-8-1)
Superman (24-3)
The Flash (Barry Allen) (20-7)
Nightwing/Robin (Dick Grayson) (18-9)
Hellboy (17-10)
Round 3 is up.