Based on ArizonaTeach’s idea from here
The rules are simple. Pick one competitor in each match-up - the one with the higher total goes on to the next round and the losers get dumped in the dollar bin. You can base your vote on any criteria you like. You can pass on a match-up if you choose. Anyone is eligible to play in any or all rounds but you can only vote once in each round. The voting for this round will end at 11:00 pm (EST) on Saturday (I moved it up 24 hours as most of the voting seemed to be at the beginning or end anyway).
The numbers are the results from Round 1.
Batman (26-1)
Professor X (Charles Xavier) (14-13)
Shadowcat (Kitty Pride) (14-13)
The Flash (Wally West) (25-2)
Nightcrawler (19-7-1)
The Tick (16-10-1)
Hawkeye (16-11)
Wonder Woman (22-5)
Wolverine (20-7)
Rogue (15-12)
Thor (23-4)
Plastic Man (17-7-3)
The Question (15-11-1)
Green Arrow (Oliver Queen) (16-11)
Swamp Thing (14-13)
Martian Manhunter (Jonn J’onzz) (22-3-2)
Spider-Man (22-5)
Rorschach (16-11)
Doctor Manhattan (18-6-3)
Iron Man (19-8)
Storm (15-12)
Green Lantern (Hal Jordan) (14-13)
Mister Fantastic (15-12)
The Hulk (18-8-1)
Superman (24-3)
Daredevil (18-9)
Captain Marvel (Billy Batson/DC/Shazam) (16-10-1)
The Flash (Barry Allen) (20-7)
Nightwing/Robin (Dick Grayson) (18-9)
Silver Surfer (22-5)
Hellboy (17-10)
Captain America (19-7-1)