If I might draw a parallel between the OP and events in the past…
Does anyone here remember PTL? Jim Bakker, Pentecostal preacher to the masses, with his loyal wife Tammy Faye. I lived for a time in Charlotte, NC, just across the border from Heritage USA, so I saw much of their rise and fall. Then, as now, there appeared to be some sort of a psychotic disconnect between the realities of the situation and the way many people interpereted it. Compare this to the nigh-spiritual reverence than many had towards Bill Clinton in 1998, decrying any indication that, yes, he did have an affair with Monica, and, yes, that he used all his word-twisting magic to avoid admitting it, even when under oath to tell the truth.
There is something about the human psyche, where we raise our idols up onto pedestals, refusing to find any fault in them. Admitting that these figures might have feet of clay is close to admitting that we, ourselves, were fooled by them. We could be otherwise intelligent, rational people, yet still our faith endures. And as the evidence piles up, the stakes get higher and higher.
We start by labeling those naysayers as merely jealous folks. Then we proclaim them nattering nabobs, nitpicking at any crack in our heros’ armor. Eventually they become ghoulish hounds from Hades, hellbent to tear down everything beautiful in this world. And then…
…when the pressure from the ludicrous obviousness of the whole situation builds to unendurable amounts, then there is a psychic explosion within the ranks of the faithful. They separate into two factions.
There are the Eternal Idolators, who would drink deep from the anal sphincter of their Hero, as if it were from the Fountain of Life. Nothing He (or She) does will ever, ever be wrong. No fact is to great to be overlooked when opining about their Savior Incarnate.
Others become the Bainsidhe Incarnate. Admitting their prior blindness, they turn into the polar opposites of the Idolators. No mitigating circumstances are relevant with regards to that living Satan figure. Anything he did in the past, everything he does in the future are only Svengali-like attempts to lure in more souls for the pyre.
It’s all part of human nature. It will keep happening again, over and over, for any polarizing figure. Calling these folks insane is labelling the entirety of humanity one Haldol away from the looney bin.
Not that we aren’t.