OK I’m sure there can’t be any possible star wars questions that haven’t been exhaustively researched and aswered on this board. However, since I’m frankly too lazy to go read through all of the lengthy threads on the subject, I’ll ask here.
If you know that this has already been addressed, a simple link to the thread will be entirely sufficient.
Questions:
Why did Grand Moff Tarkin wait for the moon of Yavin that the rebels were on to come into line of sight of the deathstar and its planet-destroying weapon?
Wouldn’t it have been much easier to just blast Yavin itself as soon as it was in range? Surely taking out the planet would have destroyed the moon as well. At the very least it would have thrown it out of (or more precisley, removed) it’s orbit and thereby causing the moon to become instantly uninhabitable?
It strikes me as entirely possible the Death Star couldn’t destroy Yavin itself even if it wanted to. Gas giants are big. You could drop Earth into Jupiter’s Great Red Spot with some room to spare. (The Great Red Spot is about twice as wide as Earth’s diameter; the north-south diameter of the GRS is about equal to Earth’s diameter. Now look at this picture of Jupiter.) Assuming Yavin IV is more-or-less Earth-sized, and assuming Yavin is at least as large as Jupiter (given Yavin’s apparently extensive system of large moons this seems plausible, and we’ve found quite a few extrasolar planets now that are bigger than Jupiter), even the Death Star may simply not have the power to blow away something as big as a gas giant.
I wonder if the death star beam would have had much of an effect on a gas giant at all. Would there be anything solid at the planet’s core to blow up or would the beam pass right through? If the beam passed through, maybe they just could have shot a blast right throught the planet and hit the moon. Or, perhaps they had to be at a specific distance for the beam to achieve the desired planet busting effect.
Hah! Hah! I rule! I am l33t! My answer was the right answer, as endorsed by the Jedi Council–I know more about Star Wars trivia than all the rest of…
Hmmm…
Uh, I mean, lucky guess for me, right? Heh. Ah, yes, Star Wars. I liked that back when I was a kid. Well, I think I shall go re-read The Iliad again. Good night.
Normally, I would counter with “Silly, shock waves can’t travel through the vacuum of space!” – but this is the Star Wars universe we’re talking about here.
However, they didn’t need to wait for the moon to clear beafor warming up the weapon (tho I suppose aiming might be part of warming up)
That could have saved a minute or so.
I’ll assume hyperspace physics made it so they had to go back into normal space on the opposite side of the planet as the moon.
Brian
Because one way or another, they needed to get the Death Star plans to the rebel leaders. If they didn’t take that chance, there would have just been more Alderaans.
Also, it’s not clear that the Rebels had the large fleet of ships that they possesed in the later movies and use to launch fighters to attack the second Death Star. We don’t see any large ships on Yavin’s moon, they may have only had x-wings at that point, in which case the only way for them to attack the Death Star was to bring it to them.